#microformats 2013-11-27
2013-11-27 UTC
tantek_, tantek, romainneutron, shaners, tobyink, barnabywalters, waterbaby999_ and charl joined the channel
tobyink joined the channel
# 
felixjet can someone help me with a microformat question please?
# felixjet on h-recipe... p-name - the name of the recipe
# felixjet but... recipes have a title, not a name, dont ?
# felixjet shoudlnt it be p-title ?
# 
barnabywalters welcome felixjet
# felixjet welcome barnabywalters
# barnabywalters title is a confusing semantic which was replaced with name for consistency
# barnabywalters name is the more generic, appropriate semantic
# felixjet but .. a dog has a name
# felixjet a person
# felixjet etc
# felixjet but a recipe?
# felixjet its a title, dont ?
# felixjet i think name is the semantic confusing here
# barnabywalters 4x more results for recipe name
# felixjet uh
pfefferle joined the channel
# felixjet not fair
# felixjet more on title
# barnabywalters felixjet: could you raise this issue on the h-recipe-feedback page on the wiki? Iām a bit busy now
# barnabywalters with links to that data
# felixjet its an issue? im fine with "name", i was just wanting to know if im really wrong
# felixjet or its opinion-based
# felixjet hehe
# barnabywalters name is more generic and consistent with the other microfomats vocabularies
# barnabywalters but if title really is a more appropriate semantic then we should look into using it
# barnabywalters hence documenting it
# felixjet ill post an issue and see what others think about it
# felixjet thx
romainneutron, waterbaby999_, Phae, benward, tswicegood, ChiefRA, lmjabreu, rknLA, twisted`, brianloveswords, tobyink, TallTed, jgay, tantek, KevinMarks2, shaners and singpolyma joined the channel
# 
KevinMarks felixjet: re 'title' - we had a collision with the title of a person from vCard - see http://microformats.org/wiki/properties
# felixjet i dont understand that
# felixjet what vcards have to do with recipes
# KevinMarks this became p-job-title
# felixjet ?
# KevinMarks microformats use each property name once, not to mean different things in differnt places
# felixjet but a recipe doesnt have a name, have a title, dont?
# KevinMarks entry-title would be the suggestion to reuse
# KevinMarks it used to be fn, which was replaced by name
# KevinMarks name vs title is a bit bikesheddy
# KevinMarks title is publication centric, name is dish centric
# KevinMarks the foodstuff is named "pumpkin pie"
brianloveswords joined the channel
# KevinMarks it might be named "Gordon Ramsay's pumpkin pie"
# KevinMarks the recipe is instructions to make the foodstuff
# KevinMarks not sure if it has a title per se
# felixjet depends on opinnion i guess
# felixjet but to me.... a recipe is some sort of publication
# felixjet like a recipe book
# felixjet thats good use for a title if you ask me
romainneutron, tantek and singpolyma joined the channel