#microformats 2025-11-07

2025-11-07 UTC
[KevinMarks], Daruma, SammoWammo, pfych, Guest6, [Ana_R], [me1850], hacdias, [social] and dale joined the channel
#
dale adminhelp
#
dale adminhelp
#
dale Does any body have an idea when the best time is to contact a wiki administrator?
#
dale adminhelp
#
[artlung] What’s your question dale?
gRegor joined the channel
#
sknebel edited /Special:Log/newusers () "created new account User:Khleedril: requested privately do document booklogging" (view diff)
#
dale Hi, I'm the user known as khleedril. Happy to converse here rather than mastodon if that suits you.
dale left the channel
#
khleedril edited /h-review (+95) "/* Examples in the Wild */" (view diff)
#
khleedril created /Talk:h-review (+296) "Created page with "With regards to p-rating, my understanding is that the value goes from p-worst to p-best, not necessarily 0-5. Whatever the meaning of p-worst and p-best needs clarifying I think, especially the bit that says p-best can be less than p-worst: can someone give an example where this might be used?"" (view diff)
#
khleedril edited /Talk:h-review (+1) (view diff)
#
gRegor Hi Khleedril, are you around in the chat? We don't usually use the wiki Talk pages much these days. Chat and/or the github issues are probably better for that.
#
gRegor There's actually a discussion about merging h-review into h-entry: https://github.com/microformats/h-entry/issues/32
#
Loqi [preview] [barnabywalters] #32 Consider merging h-review properties into h-entry
#
gRegor oh, saw the backlog, looks like that was for dale ^
[Al_Abut] joined the channel
#
khleedril created /Talk:microformats2 (+128) "Created page with "The list here does not agree with that on the h-review main page. Which is correct? I believe the list here is the proper one."" (view diff)
dale joined the channel
#
dale Hi, in the wiki there are two definitions of h-review: one on h-review's own page and one on the microformats2 page. They do not agree with each other, but I believe the latter to be correct. Does anybody have any insight into this?
#
gRegor Can you be more specific? https://microformats.org/wiki/microformats2#h-review is a summary of the spec, https://microformats.org/wiki/h-review is the spec itself. You probably want the latter, but let us know what specifically looks off about the former and we can make sure they're in sync
#
gRegor Ah, I do see `p-reviewer` on the former. That's `p-author` in the current spec, that's one difference to fix in the summary
#
gRegor And the `e-content` vs `e-description` difference. Yeah, the spec page is correct.
#
gregorlove edited /microformats2 (+48) "/* h-review */ sync with /h-review spec: p-author, dt-published, e-content" (view diff)
#
gRegor Dale++ thanks for raising that, let us know if there's anything else there
#
Loqi Dale has 1 karma over the last year
#
gRegor I actually wonder if we need to duplicate all that info that's on https://microformats.org/wiki/microformats2 vs linking to the specs
#
gRegor That might be from the time when mf2 was first being set up, so working on all the new properties and backcompat in one place made sense. Not sure, just a guess.
#
dale Are you basing your assertion on what's in the wild, or what you think ought to be correct?
#
dale The other thing I noticed on the spec page is p-rating is stated as taking values from 0-5, but I think they go from p-worst to p-best with the assumpion that they are 0 and 5 if not specified. I think this needs clarifying, especially the case when p-best is less than p-worst (is there a use-case for this?)
dale left the channel
#
gRegor The h-review spec is correct based on familiarity with it and community consensus changes in recent years. For example, `e-description` has been standardized to `e-content` based on trying to re-use properties from other micorformat objects, like `h-entry`. Similarly for `dt-published` and `p-author`
#
gRegor In absence of a `p-best` or `p-worst`, the scale is 0 to 5 with 5 being best.
#
gRegor Those two properties let you change the scale, though. Yeah, different direction of the scale is possible, though I'm not aware of any examples currently.
#
gregorlove edited /h-review (+61) "/* Examples in the Wild */ +https://indieweb.org/review#IndieWeb_Examples" (view diff)
#
gRegor Are you working on adding h-review to https://khleedril.org/dale-mellor/bookblog/?
#
gRegor Oh disregard, I found the h-review on the individual permalinks. nice!
[Murray] joined the channel