#[KevinMarks]Understand irc how? The protocol or the customs around it?
#[LewisCowles]KevinMarks, if you had awesome links to things from sysops and standards to customs, I wouldn't complain. I literally use slack out of ignorance of IRC, which I can use, and have used, but have never felt familiar with.
#jeremycherfasI have difficulty understanding why I am sometimes GuestNNNNN and sometimes my nickname, and how to switch to my nickname.
#[LewisCowles]should sign you in from who you are instead of GuestNNNNN
dckc, quite, bovej, KempfCreative, [prtksxna], marinin[t] and seekr joined the channel
#jeremycherfasThanks. The client does occasionally forget who I am, and that's part of the mystery.
marinin[t], [itsjustk], twomanytacos and [tantek] joined the channel
#[tantek]This feels like some of the most accurate analysis of Twitter/FB (maybe even Slack?) UX design focus since (perhaps even broader/clearer than) “The Argument Machine”
#@extrafaceI’ve been studying nonreactivity in buddhism. It’s one of the tactics of the path and also a goal. Today I noticed that Twitter and Facebook are built around literally giving a voice to your reactivity. Blogs were too, but they weren’t as effective. (twitter.com/_/status/1268141616717537280)
#[tantek]How can we (on the IndieWeb) design for “giving a voice to” thoughtfulness instead?
#[tantek](Feels overlapping between here and #indieweb-dev )
#[itsjustk]I'm not 100% sure what you mean by that, but i always thought that it would be cool to have CMS "packages" or distributions as drupal calls them for indieweb enabled sites, modules, theme etc. Or is that not quite what you are asking? 🙂
seekr joined the channel
#aaronpkIm super curious about what the specific mechanisms are that enable and encourage that behavior
#[itsjustk]arrr i failed to realize it was a riposte to the other comments 😳
KindTwo joined the channel
#[tantek][aaronpk] we’ve been so close with our analysis, naming of terms, and documentation over time. It was right there in front of us
#Loqireactions refer to the subset of responses/interactions with a post that are quicker, more impulsive, but still a conscious act, typically a simple UI gesture without writing any content, such as likes (reacji), reposts, bookmarks, or perhaps multiple simple UI gestures, such as selection a text range and posting a quotation of part of a post, or picking a person from a list to post an invitation as a response to seeing an event https://indieweb.org/reaction
#[jgmac1106]I avoid the phrase "giving a voice" "finding" marginalized have a voice, its a matter of removing your boot from their throat
#Loqireacji is an emoji reaction, the use of a single emoji character in response to a post, introduced as a feature by Slack[1] https://indieweb.org/reacji
#aaronpkI suspect reposts are one of them, and the reason that micro.blog doesn't have reposts
#[jgmac1106]why I prefer "owning voice" not sure...have a bunch of reflections on the term. It is a matter that argument got defined as the highest form of intellectual discourse
#[jgmac1106]I am just catching up and reading links now, I may have been a tangeant
#[tantek]This is about deliberate design not demographics
#aaronpk[jgmac1106]: The text was "giving a voice to your reactivity" which is something very different
#[jgmac1106]yes but in that design be deliberate abotu demographics
#[jgmac1106]been watching reactions on Tumblr...there is so little engagment, you see posts with 1,000s of notes but they are just likes...no note at all
oedmarap joined the channel
#[jgmac1106]I think the friction of the webmention is a good UX around reactions...I have to do it from my site, own it, invest in the time
#[tantek][jgmac1106] would be interesting to see a couple of those with screenshots for the /Tumblr page
#@extrafaceI’ve been studying nonreactivity in buddhism. It’s one of the tactics of the path and also a goal. Today I noticed that Twitter and Facebook are built around literally giving a voice to your reactivity. Blogs were too, but they weren’t as effective. (twitter.com/_/status/1268141616717537280)
#@extraface@andrealee_b I left Facebook. I have drastically reduced my Twitter time but it has kicked up in the current moment. I've always thought the reifying of reactive blog writing and commenting was suspect, lol. On the other side, you have to work at cultivating nonreactivity daily. Recommended: (twitter.com/_/status/1268158826580267010)
#[jgmac1106]ahh the interwebz...didn't somebody mess around with a token system, mean having only so many reactions in a day to give?
#[tantek]Applying scarcity to something gives it a framing as having “value”. I believe the author is noting the opposite, negative value.
#[jgmac1106]yeah just trying to think of the model, especially from a bhuddist point of view, goal is to write without the desire or as reaction
#[jgmac1106]but what if a reader had a pop up after five likes under certain time?
#[tantek]So that last tweet is an interesting criticism, yes blogs are (potentially) better than Twitter or FB, however even they could be better still
#[jgmac1106]my blog is pretty much reaction free, why I encourage people not to install analytics (if not monetizing). I dont want to write to numbers
#[jgmac1106]reaction free as not many comments...but the reactions and blog comments you see in teacher spaces are always a bit different.
#[tantek][jgmac1106] doesn’t feel like that goes far enough. Why have likes at all in your UX? What’s the behavior they’re designed for?
#[jgmac1106]I actually don't have the reaction plugin iinstalled
#[tantek]Analytics feels it’s conflating a lot of other things too
#[jgmac1106]I do likes on Twitter, but it is pretty m,uch a h/t for poems or toencourage younger scholar and teachers
#[tantek]I think that (“Twitter is good for x”) is missing the point
#[jgmac1106]it is, but isn't the author writes for engagement, reaction drives enagements, analytics measure...just sharing some of my strategies
#[jgmac1106]yeah just explaining how I do it becuase you asked me
#[tantek]Twitter’s UX is actively (re)training your brain for a maladaptive behavior.
#[tantek]Doesn’t matter if it sometimes is “for good”
#[jgmac1106]I don't own my likes I am saying, let them go by the wayside
#[jgmac1106]no liking poetry and encouraging people, I am cool with...the like is ephemeral for me...do I know I am feeding Twitters machines..yes...but can't be perfect
#[jgmac1106]I also still put stickers on papers and use the reactions in my classes as social presence
#[tantek]You’re not just feeding Twitter’s machine, you’re feeding your own reactivity “muscle”
#[jgmac1106]reactions can build communities as well
#[jgmac1106]when crafting a community of writers, I may have 30 people in the class, reactions also allow me to save time, my biggest personal cost
#[tantek]Unless you’re literally using twitter UX for your classes that sounds like something else
#[jgmac1106]I have done that but I am also talking reactions in Microsoft teams, or on our cl;ass websites, like Known
#[tantek]Also feels like an antipattern to build a community around a tool (or UX) that harms the individuals in that community personally
#[tantek]I think this may be bad enough to characterize as a dark pattern
#[jgmac1106]I get the authors point a reaction is a craving, a craving goes against fundamental Bhuddist principles
#[tantek]Yes, Buddhist and at least a few other old eastern philosophies and practices
#[tantek]Learned a bunch about non-reactivity in yoga teacher training too
#[jgmac1106]but I think I can react to content in positive ways...and I will fully admit as a teacher I take advantage of the human craving for connection
#[jgmac1106]I am also not vegetarian still, even though I know that is right,
#[tantek]Human connection is good. Unclear that “reaction” is actually providing that
#[tantek]Worse, reactions may provide the illusion of it
#[itsjustk]I've found that if you have built a community through a reactive medium like twitter, it inevitably grows too large to stay there (or at least use it as their daily driver) and so explores other tools to better facilitate that community?
#[tantek]I think the key aspect there may be discovery, not reactivity
#petermolnar"reaction" in this context, is a forced replacement for what your body (feromons), your body language, and your mimics would do to a certain scenario. Most people are not good enough with writing and words to replace them, and in most cases, it's not possible to fully susbtitute for them. That said, I believe they are useless, and a cheap imitation of a reality-feature that doesn't (yet?) exist online.
#[jgmac1106][itsjustk] we were on G+ which was actually really good community and kinda webmentiony (blogger only). Now just a web ring and an rss planet, and a twitter hashtag, and a facebook group: https://clmoocring.jgregorymcverry.com/
#[jgmac1106]and writing, and art, and music have sucha gravitational force...plus it felt a bit 1990ish, especially tiling the gif...huge waste of resources
#[jgmac1106]this is more chat but if anyone ever needs a postcard just ask about #clmooc anywhere and request and you will get one
#[itsjustk]I would take tiling gifs over full background ads :face_vomiting:
#[jgmac1106][tantek] images uploaded will edit wiki later need to go help some students
#[jgmac1106]I did add a webmention guestbook to my website but like my old guestbook nobody signed it. commented it out for now
dckc and gxt joined the channel
#[tantek]Thanks! Helps to thoughtfully document this stuff :)
#@LeonieWatsonI deactivated my #facebook account months ago because facebook could not be trusted. I've now deleted it because Mark Zuckerberg will not take a stand against racism and violence. (twitter.com/_/status/1268169353956114434)
[tw2113] joined the channel
#aaronpkthe other problem with deleting ones facebook account is that then your friends on facebook can’t really tell that you’ve deleted it or for what reason
#aaronpk(in addition to the risk of someone setting up a new fake page in your name)
#aaronpkI want to delete my facebook but I feel like it’s not enough
#[tantek]Sounds like you want to leave a tombstone or forwarder instead?
#[tantek]Deleting all your content except a post linking to where to find you could work
#LoqiIt looks like we don't have a page for "feed fatigue" yet. Would you like to create it? (Or just say "feed fatigue is ____", a sentence describing the term)
#[LewisCowles][tantek] RE: thoughtfulness, I think encourage editorial pipelines and the process we used to see in papers with spell checking, a11y, etc but also retractions would be wonderful. I've a long list of where I would like to get to. Diagrams, features and accessible content has to be a part of it, and that by nature requires thoughtfulness.
#[LewisCowles]KevinMarks. I Object to Architecture astronomy as a former contract architect I'd often see developers who were ruining products use the term to get out of change. Unfortunately all attempts at anything but steam-rollering them failed.
#[LewisCowles]KevinMarks. I Object to Architecture astronomy as a former contract architect I'd often see developers who were ruining products use the term to get out of change. Unfortunately all attempts at anything but steam-rollering them failed.
jgee, jussi^, wolftune and [prtksxna] joined the channel
#[tantek][LewisCowles] even starting with editing / editability at all would be good. Interesting that it’s one of the most asked for features on Twitter
KartikPrabhu, jussi^, wolftune, [calumryan] and [JuJu] joined the channel
#[LewisCowles]For twitter I feel like their centralisation is the limiting factor to such things in a much more easy to see way than owning our own websites
#[jgmac1106]Hey everyone we are forking Elm City Webmakers into a remote tech camp for teens...It is all passion based from yoru own website
#[jgmac1106]it is passion driven (meaning your goals and interest) and you choose podcasting, video, photo, web desgin and everyone gets coding classes
#[jgmac1106]students are asking for help learning how to organize, and we need mentors, if you have anyone who might be interested in donating a few hours a week please send my contact
#[jgmac1106]involvement and yotuh interest so far is ~90% IBPoc children so would really like Black and Brown mentors with experience or willing to model how they learn with the children, please feel free to share my contact info with anyone in your network
#[jgmac1106]teens just as fired up as anyone...want to learn digital organizing skills not using facebook....every kid hates facebook right now because of their support for Trump on free leash
wolftune joined the channel
#[jgmac1106]...IBPOC...sorry for education jargon Indigenous Black and People of Color
#[LewisCowles]Ah. [KevinMarks] I was not suggesting hegemonic control or centralisation, which I believe were two of the issues touched upon, nor community moderation, management, catalysts or Troll whispering, although I'm going to read all your links at some point in the future.
#[LewisCowles]I started writing up a blog post but short-form or long form.. Very hard to do around editorial control. Perhaps another area of my blog to break-out.
#[LewisCowles]By break-out I have an experiment where I've created an area for some posts, which are also listed on my main blog index. At some point I'll need to think about discoverability, but ironically or not, I need to sort out some of my editorial control before doing so.
seekr, [Paulo_Pinto], [snarfed], KartikPrabhu, nekr0z, kensp, [Sadik_Shahadu], wolftune and [chrisaldrich] joined the channel