#indieweb 2024-02-13

2024-02-13 UTC
[tantek] and [snarfed] joined the channel
#
[snarfed]
well, as expected, it's been a day full of hate from the vocal minority on the fediverse in response to https://snarfed.org/2024-02-12_52106 🤷
#
Loqi
[preview] [Ryan Barrett] Fediverse! I’ve been building a bridge to Bluesky, and they’re turning on federation soon, which means my bridge will be available soon too. You’ll be able to follow people on Bluesky from here in the fediverse, and vice versa. Bluesky is a bro...
#
[snarfed]
(and a decent amount of love too, granted)
#
[snarfed]
I may be one of the main characters there today
#
gRegor
How does this work if we already have a bluesky account?
#
capjamesg
[snarfed] I’ll respond in chat.
#
aaronpk
i'm so tired of everyone being so angry all the time
#
[snarfed]
gRegor you mean bridging your site to bluesky? it doesn't try to de-dupe or merge with any existing account
#
gRegor
I get the frustration if it has the appearance that your posts might show up in a social network you don't want to be on. though I'm still not really clear if that's what this is doing.
#
[snarfed]
same as BF's fediverse bridging
#
[snarfed]
yeah that is what this does. it's opt out, but the angry vocal minority on fediverse doesn't like opt out
#
[snarfed]
aaronpk++
#
Loqi
aaronpk has 9 karma in this channel over the last year (117 in all channels)
hedy- and shoesNsocks joined the channel
#
[tantek]
aaronpk, "everyone being so angry all the time" is Twitter problem that Mastodon successfully recreated by copying Twitter’s UX
mretka_weechat, sivoais_, jacky, rocto_, sknebel_ and Nonsvch_ joined the channel
#
aaronpk
indeed
bleb and hacdias joined the channel
#
[KevinMarks]
Partly ux, partly culture.
#
[KevinMarks]
Potch seems to be reinventing OStatus https://toot.cafe/@potch/111921390435586597
#
[KevinMarks]
Oops that's for #indieweb-dev
#
[tantek]
[KevinMarks] Mastodon is more toxic now than early Twitter. I claim the UX drove the culture, and I believe that's the point of Derek's Argument Machine post
#
[tantek]
in contrast: every time I randomly browse some http://micro.blog thread, I don't find any flames like on Mastodon / Twitter
#
[tantek]
despite having a similar (not the same) UX/features
#
[KevinMarks]
The ux did drive the culture, but there was some lag as we had a better culture early on. https://www.fastcompany.com/3063060/a-brief-history-of-the-angry-social-network
geoffo joined the channel
#
Loqi
[preview] [Manton Reece] Good interview at Platformer with Eugen Rochko. Some of his thoughts on AT Protocol: My hope still is that — fingers crossed — when Meta starts federating with Mastodon that the critical mass will be large enough that Bluesky developers will jus...
#
[tantek]
in particular: "Because Threads is opt-in for the fediverse and Bluesky keeps growing, ActivityPub might not end up dwarfing AT Proto the way we expected." indeed
#
[tantek]
really curious what it is about Bluesky that is drawing people in. not having used the UI yet myself (though with the Bridgy POSSE/backfeed support I'm prioritizing that above Threads POSSE I think) I admit I don't have any direct experience that explains it
#
[snarfed]
it may have just been one of the better "like Twitter but not Twitter"s
#
[KevinMarks]
It's the twitter experience combined with an invite model that made it seem like a club, so it attracted a lot of twitter posters and media people
#
[tantek]
a-ha, the invite model attracting an "insider crowd" which then attracted the folks influenced by them and so on
#
[KevinMarks]
Right, a less techy crowd than mastodon.
epoch joined the channel; shoesNsocks left the channel
#
[Al_Abut]
I did a light bit of user research last year with friends that are scientists on bluesky to see why they ended up there as part of the exodus of science twitter
#
[Al_Abut]
lots of factors but basically came down to ux - they all tried mastodon and bounced like immediately
#
[Al_Abut]
this is probably news to no one, just thought it was interesting to hear from a user pool that’s not techies but also not the super casual Threads types
#
[Al_Abut]
I wonder if this fragmentation of social circles is the new normal…
#
epoch
what was old is new again?
#
Loqi
It looks like we don't have a page for "old is new again" yet. Would you like to create it? (Or just say "old is new again is ____", a sentence describing the term)
#
epoch
(not what I meant, loqi)
jacky joined the channel
#
jacky
[snarfed]'s right re: BluekSky; it's the closest clone that gives a near-identical (for those not as tech tilted) experience _and_ the strong move of peoples' social graphs manually to the platform helped out a lot
#
jacky
"social graph" here being the conventional definition
hacdias_, eitilt, tPoltergeist, nshire and [Murray] joined the channel; nshire left the channel
#
[Murray]
RE: science Twitter -> BlueSky: there also just seems to be more interest for science communication on BlueSky. Popular scicomm people have managed to grow very large followings there passively, whereas they've largely floundered on Fedi (unless they're climate scientists)
#
[Murray]
also snarfed++
#
Loqi
snarfed has 38 karma in this channel over the last year (121 in all channels)
niho, jjuran and mahboubine joined the channel
#
mahboubine
a few weeks ago I removed the www. from my domain
#
mahboubine
now I discovered a problem, my old webmentions are using a target with www. so if I remove the www. from my api request to the webmentions server I no longer get the old webmentions
#
mahboubine
and if I keep the www. I don't get new mentions
[marksuth] joined the channel
#
mahboubine
is there a way to transfer webmentions sent to www. url to the new one?
#
[KevinMarks]
You could request both and combine them
#
mahboubine
[KevinMarks]: that's what I am doing now but I hoped for a cleaner solution
tPoltergeist, mretka, barnaby, xcv, Guest6, [Jo] and [jacky] joined the channel
#
[Murray]
A thought on the bridging debate: could it be opt-in or else anonymised? So if I've opted in, my accounts can be paired, and my name, avatar, etc. is all synced, but if not then comments are shown as coming from, effectively, a http://Brid.gy bot account? (Obviously I have no idea what the behind-the-scenes technical toll might be or if that's even possible)
#
[Murray]
Similarly, if someone who hasn't opted in has their post shared to a different service, then it would be anonymised too
#
[Murray]
I understand there may be some concern still over the implications of copying the content and losing the attribution, but people do that all of the time via screenshots and other third-party services like RSS converters, which people on both platforms seem perfectly fine with
#
sknebel
stripping attribution seems worse
#
sknebel
for both sides
#
[Murray]
I'm not sure. A lot of the arguments I'm seeing are about not wanting to draw in attention. Anonymising things would help with that
#
[Murray]
(though I'm also not saying that this fixes everything/anything; just throwing it out there)
#
sknebel
thats not something you can default-decide for everyone
[Joe_Crawford], Guest6 and [Joel_Auterson] joined the channel
#
[Joel_Auterson]
sorry you're having such a bad time with this [snarfed]++, unfortunately fedi people can be some of the most irritating on the web. doubly frustrating that the anger seems to be coming from a deeply uninformed position. hope you're all good and can step away from it for a bit if need be
AramZS joined the channel
#
Loqi
[preview] [snarfed] #166 add LinkedIn support
gremblo_gremblo[ joined the channel
eitilt and Ezri1 joined the channel
[benatwork] joined the channel
#
[benatwork]
^ They seem to have deleted the post
#
[benatwork]
But upshot was that they're spending another 6 months experimenting with Mastodon and will look at how they can publish from BBC properties using ActivityPub
#
[campegg]
[benatwork] I still see it 🤔
#
[KevinMarks]
oh, it's still up for me, but maybe my BBC cert is working
#
[benatwork]
oh weird
#
sknebel
works here
#
[benatwork]
it's flitting back and forth
#
[benatwork]
was a 404 a moment ago
#
[benatwork]
I wonder if it just got Slashdotted by the Mastodon deluge (ActivityPunted?)
#
[benatwork]
anyway, cool, will republish my bookmarks 😬
[aciccarello] and [pfefferle] joined the channel; alecjonathon left the channel
#
[Joe_Crawford]
My model of the world was formed when people *wanted* their phone number in the white pages so they could be reached. But even then there were people who wanted to be "unlisted" - I believe in the US they paid for that part of their phone service. It is nontrivial to accommodate both (legitimate) needs in any shared system.
mahboubine and [manton] joined the channel
#
[manton]
Thinking about Bridgy, Bluesky, and Mastodon… It often feels that (some) Mastodon folks care more about Mastodon as a platform than the open web as a platform. Not sure if that’s completely fair, but framing it this way has made my view of debates around public posts more clear.
#
[manton]
When I post to my blog, my posts are on the web, and so (hopefully) make the web a little better… or worse, depending on your view of my writing. 😉 But it’s a different mindset than posting to a specific platform where I mostly expect my followers to see it.
#
[manton]
This is also directly related to js;dr, because permalinks on Mastodon are (arguably) barely on the web at all.
[KevinMarks] joined the channel
#
[KevinMarks]
well, they are if you append '/embed'
#
[tantek]
[manton] there's the persistent web, the thing that lasts over time, that search engines see and index, that Internet Archive archives, and then there's the https API endpoints on web servers "web", the thing that I've started calling the ephemeral web, the set of things that are here today, briefly, gone tomorrow
#
[tantek]
"permalinks on Mastodon are (arguably) barely on the web at all" <-- precisely, and essentially blank, you have to use a metaformats parser to extract their meta tags into anything useful whatsoever, e.g. from the Internet Archive
#
Loqi
[tantek]: would you mind moving this conversation (API, endpoints, parser) to #indieweb-dev? thanks!
#
[tantek]
lol yes
#
[aciccarello]
Noticed a "sign in required" post on bluesky that showed it's content with JS disabled. Seems like a bug.
bterry joined the channel
#
[snarfed]
oh wow yeah that does
#
[aciccarello]
But even in the model that Mastodon posts are not part of the web, they still include metadata for link previews which breaks that "not public" piece.
#
[tantek]
aciccarello, indeed, we could treat that link preview information as the only public part of Mastodon posts and treat them accordingly
buj and alecjonathon joined the channel
#
[KevinMarks]
I like the 'instead of fediverse, call it the archipelago' bit of this https://nora.codes/post/the-fediverse-is-already-dead/
alecjonathon joined the channel
#
buj
I see this is a yet another thing I can add to my nonexistent website
alecjonathon and dmowitz joined the channel
#
[manton]
[tantek] The “ephemeral web” is a good phrase. Things that use web technology but sort of come and go, not indexed or accessible later.
to2ds joined the channel
#
to2ds
Still waiting for Web 1.0 to become fashionable again.
#
[tantek]
to2ds, it never left 😄
#
[tantek]
[manton] indeed. I really want to use a ocean / waves / beach / sandcastles metaphor for this
#
[tantek]
social media is the froth generated when waves crash upon the shore
#
[tantek]
briefly loud & exciting but fades quickly with no evidence it was ever there, except for perhaps a few grains of sands moved around a bit
#
aaronpk
lol nice
#
to2ds
[tantek]++
#
Loqi
[tantek] has 20 karma in this channel over the last year (104 in all channels)
#
[tantek]
is that too much of a hot take?
#
[tantek]
or should I work on completing the metaphor with diagrams and such?
#
to2ds
To me, social media is the toxic waste that washes up on the shore.
#
[tantek]
# not_all_social_media 😂
#
to2ds
[tantek] True.
#
[Joel_Auterson]
xitter certainly is
#
to2ds
It all circles back to the fact that it needs to be easier and more intuitive for the non-techie to establish their own Internet prescence.
#
[tantek]
yes and let's try to avoid othering with phrases like non-techie! how about "people in general to establish their own Internet presence"?
#
to2ds
[tantek] Yes. Much better phrasing.
#
to2ds
Proper #indieweb finesse is an art!
jacky, gRegor and aaron joined the channel
#
aaron
^on the topic of it being easier/more intuitive for non-techies to establish their own internet presence, curious what the community thinks of what we've been hacking on: https://getrealnice.com
#
Loqi
aaron: sl007 left you a message on 2017-07-10 at 7:45pm UTC: https://indieweb.org/2017/Dortmund
#
[tantek]
^ that's got to be the longest delayed message ever here, also I think that was intended for aaronpk
#
[tantek]
welcome aaron! do you have a personal site?
#
aaron
hah, I do! https://aaroncohn.com
#
[tantek]
this is beautiful!
#
aaron
will take it! ;)
#
[tantek]
I see the screenshot of your personal site on getrealnice — did you use getrealnice to start/setup http://aaroncohn.com?
#
aaron
yep, entirely built on realnice. whole goal is to make it easier for anyone to have a simple little home on the internet on theirname [dot] com
#
aaron
we thought there needed to be something that felt like google docs, and also let you connect to a custom domain without you paying $$
#
[tantek]
aaron++ realnice++
#
Loqi
aaron has 1 karma over the last year
#
Loqi
realnice has 1 karma over the last year
#
[tantek]
especially well done with using what you make
#
[tantek]
what is use what you make
#
Loqi
use what you make is an IndieWeb principle that encourages creators to use the applications, tools, libraries, code, designs, documentation that they create, in particular on their personal website, and the counterpart of the make what you need principle https://indieweb.org/use_what_you_make
#
[aciccarello]
Wow, a one time purchase option is rare these days
#
[aciccarello]
Also love the free starter option with a domain!
#
[aciccarello]
realnice++
#
Loqi
realnice has 2 karma over the last year
#
[aciccarello]
I would love if this get more people into having their own page online.
#
jacky
same; this model would work, biggest hurdle for folks whenever I try to nudge is getting a domain name (esp since it feels so permanent in relation to other things online)
#
[tantek]
much friendlier than navigating GitHub static pages for example
#
[aciccarello]
It looks like there's a linkedin import? That seems smart.
aaronpk, [Paul_Robert_Ll] and hamsa joined the channel
#
capjamesg
aaron Welcome to the community!
#
capjamesg
I love the Britney Spears fact!
#
capjamesg
I have day-dreamed about making Taylor Swift's website.
#
capjamesg
realnice looks amazing, too!
aaron joined the channel
#
aaron
Gifting everyone a free domain is a big bet to get people over the hump. We used to recommend Google Domains a lot to people who had never bought a domain before, but since they got sold to Squarespace, it's been a bummer.
#
[tantek]
Indeed Google didn't provide good support there
#
aaron
FWIW, it's really hard to find a domain registrar to recommend to less-technical folks who are intimidated by the whole thing. Namecheap and Cloudflare tend to be a little too complicated :/ Porkbun is decent too, but not a lot of folks have heard of them so I think it scares them off
#
aaron
Even though we give folks (even users who don't pay us a dime) a free domain for the first year with IONOS, that's still where we see the biggest dropoff in users giving up on making a personal site
#
aaron
re: the linkedin import, that's in beta, but pretty magic when it works 🪄 the other big barrier for a lot of folks spinning up an indie internet presence is not so much the technical stuff, but rather it's writing about themselves. the AI stuff doesn't feel quite human yet, but pulling picture/headline/summary from linkedin is a good starting point. if anyone wants to play with it, it's https://getrealnice.com/10secondsite and the pw: is sofast
#
[aciccarello]
Also welcome to California aaron. We've got a few people in Southern California. I'm in Oceanside.
to2ds joined the channel
#
to2ds
aaron - writing about oneself can feel awkward at first.
#
gRegor
I'm thinking about trying porkbun after I saw Nick was trying them out.
#
gRegor
LinkedIn onboarding to a personal website is a great idea, love it. realnice++
#
Loqi
realnice has 3 karma over the last year
#
gRegor
Welcome and hello from San Diego
#
[aciccarello]
I had considered using LinkedIn as the source data for my website's resume page but their API seemed more complicated than I wanted to deal with.
#
aaron
oh yeah, the LinkedIn API is hot garbage (by design). they *really* don't want anyone scraping it. we get around it by using the proxycurl API, which is not perfect but not bad
#
Loqi
friendly reminder [aciccarello] aaron, would you mind moving this conversation (API, scraping) to #indieweb-dev? thanks!
#
[aciccarello]
I don't need to get anymore technical than that
#
[aciccarello]
But yeah, not really usable
#
aaron
haha that's fair! fun fact, realnice is 98% built on no-code via https://bubble.io
#
[aciccarello]
Woah, that's crazy
#
capjamesg
Impressive!
#
[aciccarello]
I imagine there will be a lot more of those tools in the next decade
#
aaron
we hope so. I think Squarespace, Wix, and Wordpress were amazing when they launched for getting more people on the internet. but over time they just got more features and more complexity. so it crowds out a lot of people.
#
aaron
we also took a ton of inspo from wedding website builders like zola and theknot. weddings are the only time when friends of mine who ordinarily would *never* be able to put a website on the internet actually do it. and I'd argue it's because those are "single-purpose" website builders, whereas Squarespace, Wix, Wordpress, and the like are "general purpose" site builders. the single-purpose ones are 10x easier.
jacky joined the channel
#
[Joe_Crawford]
Great tool aaron - welcome - also howdy from California (San Diego in my case) - though I have lived off and on in L.A. (and Orange and Ventura counties) many times and still love many things Los Angeles.
#
[KevinMarks]
Did you look at omg.lol?
#
[aciccarello]
Oh yeah, I forgot they had profile pages https://foobar.omg.lol/
#
[KevinMarks]
They started with profile pages and have spawned a lot since
#
Loqi
[manton] has 11 karma in this channel over the last year (42 in all channels)
#
Loqi
[preview] [Manton Reece] Introducing notes in Micro.blog
[campegg] joined the channel
#
[campegg]
gRegor, I switch from Hover to Porkbun after reading Nick's piece and have been pretty happy with it. Although the lower pricing has me considering a few more domain purchases (the fact that a few dollars made me reconsider should be signal enough that I don't really need them, but whatever)
#
gRegor
hehe, the domain struggle is real :)
#
gRegor
Anyone with opinions/recommendations on Porkbun or others, feel free to update: https://indieweb.org/personal-domain#Opinions/Recommendations
#
[manton]
@gRegor Thanks!
to2ds joined the channel
#
to2ds
[manton]++ That is a cool feature!
#
Loqi
[manton] has 12 karma in this channel over the last year (43 in all channels)
geoffo, eitilt, a51, dmowitz, jboy and aaron joined the channel; dmowitz left the channel
#
aaron
I like omg.lol ! they're vibes are on point too.
#
aaron
and yes, the domain struggle is *so* real. we've also been kinda recommending https://spaceship.com — made by Namecheap, but with not-awful UX. they're the new cool kid on the domain block
#
[KevinMarks]
Hover used to offer a domain reg api, did that go away?
#
[tantek]
what is Hover
#
Loqi
Hover is a domain registrar with good ux and customer service https://indieweb.org/Hover