#meta 2026-10-29

2026-10-29 UTC
#
kaja.sknebel.net
edited /User:Kaja.sknebel.net/upcoming-hwcs (+10) "update from events.indieweb.org"
(view diff)
JadedBlueEyes15 joined the channel
JadedBlueEyes15 joined the channel
lanodan joined the channel
#
artlung.com
created /Category:Link_management (+144) "Link management"
(view diff)
#
kaja.sknebel.net
edited /User:Kaja.sknebel.net/upcoming-hwcs (-10) "update from events.indieweb.org"
(view diff)
#
artlung.com
edited /AI_policy (+121) "/* See Also */ NLnet Publishes More Stringent Generative AI Policy"
(view diff)
#
Loqi
[[IndieWeb]] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=IndieWeb&diff=1382547019&oldid=prev Rbfoxjr2: Fixed incorrect references formatting – You can help!
sp1ff joined the channel
#
kaja.sknebel.net
edited /User:Kaja.sknebel.net/upcoming-hwcs () "(-525) update from events.indieweb.org"
(view diff)
#
kaja.sknebel.net
edited /Template:next-hwc (+0) "update next date from events.indieweb.org"
(view diff)
#
iwc-archive-bot
Created https://indieweb.org/events/2026-10-28-hwc-pacific. Please review the page to ensure the document is correctly formatted and remove any unnecessary text.
#
jamesg.blog
created /events/2026-10-28-hwc-pacific (+6512) "Created event page using IndieWeb events / Etherpad archiver"
(view diff)
ben left the channel
#
GWG
Wondering what people think of the idea of including tools used in the UX and design principle (#7). I think we have focused too much on what we used to build things over what we built and want to clarify what I see as the intent of the principle. I like a good plumbing conversation as much as anyone.. but it is pivoting us away from the experience
#
jonwhite.me
created /User:Jonwhite.me (+106) "Created page with "== Intro == I'm a software engineer in the Philadelphia area. I blog at [https://jonwhite.me jonwhite.me]""
(view diff)
#
GWG
We've always been concerned that we end up too developer or development centric
#
[capjamesg]
GWG I too much prefer UX/design discussions but I don’t think we should say that design is more important than tools used. There are reasonable ethical, social, and environmental objections to AI tools right now, for example, that I think we would be ascribing a lower importance if we said “UX and design is more important than protocols, formats, data models, schema, tools used, etc.”
#
[capjamesg]
I understand we definitely don’t want discussions to be dominated by developer chat, but I don’t think this policy will help with that. Rather, I think it would make people feel less comfortable when they feel it is appropriate to voice a concern about a tool that may be used in the community.
#
[capjamesg]
https://brennan.day/normalized-fascism-in-open-source-12-million-given-to-dhh/ is a prime example of a personal website being used not only to challenge the use of a tool, but to garner attention doing so. His post also notes the creator of Pagecord, which implements IndieWeb standards (https://indieweb.org/Pagecord), is among the patrons.
#
GWG
I think more important doesn't mean not important at all... but where do you think is a good place to address this as a principle without removing a legitimate discussion about concerns about using things?
#
GWG
Or are you saying it isn't a principle we should highlight?
#
GWG
We've been objecting to silos for years... I think that's not inconsistent with people using them
#
[capjamesg]
We do say “AKA UX before plumbing.” at the end of the principle which I like.
[snarfed] joined the channel
#
[capjamesg]
Sorry for reference everyone we are talking about #7 on https://indieweb.org/principles 🙌
#
GWG
Does plumbing include tooling? I think it does, but it isn't in /plumbing
#
GWG
Is tooling in plumbing?
#
[capjamesg]
Could you share an example of the kind of discussion you want to discourage and encourage?
#
[capjamesg]
I think that might help us figure out exactly what change is going to help lead to the envisioned outcome.
#
[tantek]
good discussion! also have mixed feelings
#
[social]
Agreeing with [tantek]
#
[social]
It is tough as IndieWeb is quite diverse with interests and capabilities. Having balance is good, but also having pockets where people who want to go deeper is good as well.
#
[capjamesg]
That’s a good point. I think for HWC, if a discussion comes up enough, we might want to intervene and say “hey, we notice this has been coming up a lot lately, maybe you’d like to run a pop up on it?”
#
[capjamesg]
Our digital gardens pop up for example was successful IIRC.
#
[tantek]
agreed to direct folks who want to go deep on a specific tool (AI or otherwise) to consider proposing, hosting a pop-up on that tool (or approach)
#
GWG
[tantek]: Exactly...
#
GWG
I'm just proposing we guide people to discussions that don't get too plumbing heavy on HWC specifically
#
[capjamesg]
GWG++ I like that idea.
#
Loqi
GWG has 3 karma in this channel over the last year (65 in all channels)
#
[capjamesg]
I don’t think updating our principles is the way to do it. I think we should issue that guidance to HWC facilitators for them to adopt as they feel appropriate.
#
GWG
And as a general indieweb principle, we focus on what we build...not as much on what we use to build it
#
GWG
That isn't ignoring it, it's just saying where it falls
#
tantek.com
edited /AI_policy (+1464) "/* Brainstorming */ add thoughts on AI-policy guidance for HWC in particular, problem statement and possible solution"
(view diff)
#
[tantek]
[capjamesg] GWG for your review: https://indieweb.org/AI_policy#tantek
#
[tantek]
agreed [capjamesg] — guidance for HWC facilitators is a better path for this than tweaking principles
#
[artlung]
An HWC ought to be relevant and substantive to the folks participating in it. Specific topic rules are unlikely to fit every meeting. But I am in favor of moderators managing conversation flow to try to hit that goal. It's what I do, and doing so without hurting feelings, ideally, but not always.
#
[tantek]
they should be relevant to the meetup topic/name, not just a random zoom social - we have co-unworking for that
#
[tantek]
*homebrew* implying something you have made yourself, typically for yourself
#
[tantek]
*website* about your *website* not your agents, not your personal note-taking, etc.
#
[tantek]
*club* as in informal, focused on hobbyists. this is not LinkedIn
#
jamesg.blog
edited /style-guide (-107) "/* capjamesg */ change url"
(view diff)
[Leo] joined the channel
#
GWG
I might change cut off to redirect
[manton] joined the channel
#
GWG
I need to be redirected on a regular basis
#
kaja.sknebel.net
edited /User:Kaja.sknebel.net/upcoming-hwcs (+166) "update from events.indieweb.org"
(view diff)
#
iwc-archive-bot
Created https://indieweb.org/events/2026-10-29-front-end-study-hall. Please review the page to ensure the document is correctly formatted and remove any unnecessary text.
#
jamesg.blog
created /events/2026-10-29-front-end-study-hall (+7837) "Created event page using IndieWeb events / Etherpad archiver"
(view diff)
#
artlung.com
edited /events/2026-10-29-front-end-study-hall (+257) "some adjustments, including an appropriately used ruby tag"
(view diff)
#
artlung.com
created /ai_policy (+23) "redirect"
(view diff)
barnaby and [Morgan_M] joined the channel