b0bg0d, ShishKabab, josephboyle and cweiske joined the channel
#Loqicweiske: sandeepshetty left you a message 8 hours, 14 minutes ago: IMO, send a webmention when a link is bookmarked but don't send one for voting because it seems like an action on "your" software rather than on the link that was bookmarked. Does that make sense?
#sandeepshettytommorris: also your h-card doesn't have an author url, do you prefer people linking to the email isntead?
b0bg0d joined the channel
#sandeepshetty!tell tommorris: want to send a pingback for http://www.sandeep.io/49 but I can't seem to find the pingback headers/link rel. Wondering how barnabywalters sent you the pingback...
#tanteksandeepshetty - share has been so watered down it that all it means at this point is "do something"
#tantekso if you find yourself thinking, oh I should call this "share", then what it really means is that you're having trouble coming up with a specific verb, or specific UI for a specific verb, and you're falling back to a ( DO SOMETHING ) button
#tanteklet me see if I can dig up the post on this
#tantekhmm - apparently I say "share" in posts quite often
#sandeepshetty:) do you have a suggestion given the context in that post? I've linked to an example post there where I just have a link and I do that very often...
#tantekmight have been called "remaindered links" also
#tanteksandeepshetty - re: http://www.sandeep.io/47 - people *do* post photos on Twitter ever since Twitter started natively hosting pic.twitter.com photos and built-in photo taking/posting into their apps.
#tanteknot sure about video - I don't know if they support posting videos to pic.twitter.com
#sandeepshettyas a reader it appears a link that i click to get more details on atleast on mobile...
#aaronpkinterestingly, photos on twitter are still just links to the photo. it's just that twitter built the service
#sandeepshettyand previews are just that... preview of *links*
#sandeepshettytwitter doesn't say you've shared a photo... it just adds a lionk to your tweet... unlike fb
#aaronpkit's the same way I posted this photo as a note, http://aaron.pk/n4Ns2 even though the file itself is under the same path as the note text
#tantekaaronpk - that's an interesting distinction. I can see what you mean. It's like Twitter built a partial photo hosting silo, that you can only access through their note posting silo as a side-effect.
#tantekOne distinction is that there are separate pic.twitter.com permalink URLs for the photo posts themselves
#sandeepshettythey extended the facebook og approach to photos
#tantekand those are the ones that get put in tweets
#aaronpkthat's true, twitter has even one more level of indirection since the link isn't to the JPG, it's to an HTML page
#tantekand that HTML page is their photo hosting service
#tantekthat's my point, Twitter *does* have a photo silo
#tantekaaronpk - nah - links to external stuff opens in new tabs across many social services, and links to native posts in those services opens in the same tab/window
#tantekI think you're wanting to put Twitter in a box instead of looking at the preponderance of evidence of the behavior of the system
#tantekand how that behavior resembles others' behavior
friedcell, eschnou and b0bg0d joined the channel
#tantek.comcreated /like (+754) "stub with real world indieweb example from sandeepshetty" (view diff)
#tanteksandeepshetty - ok your real world indieweb example of a "like" post type is worthy of capturing and documenting as something different - since you've chosen to give it an interesting and distinctive appearance / presentation
#sandeepshettyok I'm back... the recursive linking on the fullscreen photo on twitter is weird
#sandeepshettyre "done yet" and "could do", it's useful when stuff us possible but not done yet but you are right in this case: I don't think twitter will open external service links in place
#sandeepshettylet me reframe this in the context of what I want to do.. I would just treat photos as previews.... like aaronpk does
#sandeepshettylastely re "share" : even if it means "do something" it's a better verb than "do something" and as a long time Android user I think it works very well
#sandeepshettyjust like the http verb "post" is better than "do something"
#tantekbut "post" is not "do something" - it has more specific semantics
#tantek"do something" includes all kinds of things like mailto: etc.
#sandeepshettytantek: thanks for writing that up... I'll add a screenshot ot it.
#tantekand a quick stub about what's displayed *on* posts ( http://indiewebcamp.com/likes ) as opposed to "like" posts themselves - which are two different things
#tantek(not going to repeat the "reply" post vs. "comments" section of a post mistake)
#tanteksandeepshetty - great! thanks for pioneering the "like" post type on the indie web :)
#sandeepshettytantek: Re "share" is just a pretend verb It's not, and has a very real social context
#sandeepshettyI'll choose to disagree :) especially given the fact that I'm using it in the same way that millions of facebook users are used to
#tanteksandeepshetty - ok, re: reclaim. so how you would you precisely define "share" different than Google/Android's meaningless version (do something), or just a synonym for "post" or "send"?
#sandeepshettyalso another interesting thing with converspace is that like is not a different post type.. they are all posts just with different verbs
#sandeepshettywhich is why photos doesn't make sense in my context
#tanteksounds like your conceptual model might be getting in the way of a useful feature ;)
#sandeepshettyI was just implementing showing comments on my site... it looks like everyone is showing "name" or "summary" because they are plaintext..
#sandeepshettyinstead of the content which seems to be the "right" thing to do with comments..
#tanteksandeepshetty, aaronpk - didn't we have this discussion in IRC already? whether you get the content from "summary" or "content", if you want plain text, you have to strip tags yourself.
#sandeepshettywe did , I created /plaintext that day but everyone seems to agree on showing name or summary right now ... I think we should show content (which is why I have hidden plaintext content)
#sandeepshettytantek: thanks that help... I should get into the habit of looking at the wiki first ... though I wish those sections/page were linked to irc discussion
#Loqitommorris: sandeepshetty left you a message 9 hours, 58 minutes ago: want to send a pingback for http://www.sandeep.io/49 but I can't seem to find the pingback headers/link rel. Wondering how barnabywalters sent you the pingback...
#tommorrissandeepshetty: yes, was going to answer that. the 'pingbacks' on my site are currently fake. it's just frontend. I add them manually. I need to wire up pingback/webmention at some point
#tommorrisalso, barcamp this weekend. should give an indieweb session
#tantekso the close parenthesis got included as part of the TLD
#sandeepshettyactually it's assuming ) as part of the tld
#sandeepshettybecause it shouldn't accept a ) before a /
#sandeepshettyit would still break but break differently
#sandeepshettyI mean the way it is interpreting it right now
#tantekok I just checked and my cassis.js auto_link handles your text just fine: auto_link("Just implemented the ability to send [WebMentions](http://webmention.org)/Pingback.")
#tantekso yes, his code should be handling it better. that being said, you can publish more strictly by putting a trailing slash on top level URLs like that
#sandeepshettywith the trailing slash it becomes a valid...
#sandeep.ioedited /share (-254) "Removed reclaiming section since it's not needed IMO, and added a comment to criticism counter." (view diff)
#tantek.comedited /2013/Guest_List (+137) "sort Rob Lord, update counts, note duplicate URL usage for apprentice, note product URL rather than personal URL" (view diff)
#tantek.comedited /share (+697) "provide examples section, and start listing examples of sites / tools / platforms that have made share meaningless" (view diff)
#tantek10 days left til indiewebcamp 2013 and 10 spots left!
#sandeepshettyshared an update: time for me to get some shut eye :)
#tantek.comedited /share (+192) "follow-up - this is not Wikipedia, we demonstrate points here with original research, as documented with real world examples" (view diff)
#tantek.comedited /share (+496) "/* Criticism */ majority people perception is unnecessary if sites are adopting a convention - that's sufficient "proof". provide real world example site UIs as (counter-)examples" (view diff)
#tantekhmm - something changed with the Twitter API and it looks my snowflake POSSE code to Twitter is busted.
#tantek(insert Twitter API maintenance tax whinging here)
#brettwitter needs a meta API, so that people can develop off that, and the meta API would be used to accomidate all their random changes for lots of people
#tantekbret I believe that's been tried, it was called WSDL ;)
#tantekoh and then Google tried again, with their ill-fated "Web Intents"