#gRegor`That confusion of pumpio and FOSS monocultural attitudes and indieweb is unfortunate. :/
#rhiarothere's probably a whiff of ind.ie in with the confusion
#tantekrhiaro: yes that keeps rearing its head too
#tantekrhiaro: if you find issues that you think are worth documenting (i.e. aren't just ind.ie confusion, which is a separate problem), you could try adding them here: http://indiewebcamp.com/diversity
#GWGThe truth is, I like Indieweb over things like Pump.io because we are building things anyone can interact with even if they have no idea what we're doing.
#tantekGWG, right. No pump.io solution does anything to "federate" with existing silos the way that indieweb POSSE / PESOS etc. do
#gRegor`CollectQT is "A (Q)ueer (T)rans (Collect)ive for rebuilding your internets. Currently forming a new social network call Quirell" and LynnMagic is referring to pumpio here https://twitter.com/LynnMagic/status/579780867121242112
#LoqiCollectQT is a project to build a LGBTQ-aware social network silo which is currently documented as a series of issues on Gitlab, based on shortcomings of existing silos https://indiewebcamp.com/CollectQT
#gRegor`No, because I was already going to add it tantek ;)
KartikPrabhu, snarfed and NerdAcid joined the channel
#ben_thatmustbemeoh, btw, tantek, I already left a message for barnaby, I had a test case already but I don't think i had updated the pull request to include it
#gRegor`No, just commenting on that part... still reading through what you wrote.
#KartikPrabhuyeah I know the button thingie has HTML in it, but hard to automate that given the URL
#gRegor`Does Flickr have mf2? Or how are you getting it?
#tantekKartikPrabhu: no to "should parse the HTML on the page" but rather, document it as an *example* of an HTML only (no script needed) photo embed code
#tantekand it was ok that morning demos took so long
#tantekpeople had lots of inspiring stuff to show!
#ben_thatmustbemeyes, but i feel like going around the room like that without getting up to the podium made people feel like they had to show something off
#ben_thatmustbemenot necessarily bad, but it did limit us to 4 blocks instead of 5
#tantekand I think as long as we frame it as, you can show anything on your personal site you like, or you can pass if you don't want to - then I think it balances well with opportunity / accessibility, vs. how much it makes people feel like they should show something
#zachdonovanGWG: I work out of WeWork (a coworking conglomerate). There's a bunch of common space available for events that we could use. I'll talk to the community managers tomorrow.
#GWGzachdonovan: I'd talk to my employer, but I work out in Nassau. We really need a venue in Manhattan, because you can attract people from the whole metropolitan area.
#zachdonovanGWG: yep. I used to live in Westchester - good luck getting anyone to trek up there! :)
#tantekWestchester? like where Xavier's school for the gifted is? ;)
#tantekand on that note I need to go get some food
j12t joined the channel
#ben_thatmustbemetantek, theres another reference to The Internship in there
#KevinMarks_Rhiaro you could use unmung.com to translate from triples if you make an rss 1.0 feed (which is full of triples, if in a somewhat unfashionable form)
#KevinMarks_I have been trying to engage with collectqt, but I may be sounding mansplainy by pointing to prior projects
#KevinMarks_I wish them success, and want to help.
#cuibonoboKevinMarks__: sealioning is in the eye of the beholder, i think. i was only commenting on how piping tweets into the IRC might affect that perception
#KevinMarks___Of course, if that's how she thinks of it, me apologising today only makes it more sealiony
#KevinMarks___There is a problem with the wiki sign-in requiring your own domain, not subdomain, and hence being exclusive in the way ashe dislikes, even though the broader indieweb principles do not assume that you bought a domain
#Loqisealioning is a term for intrusive attempts to engage someone with questions and requests for evidence for their claims https://indiewebcamp.com/sealioning
#gRegor`I think that's a good point about the tweets piped in here + sealioning.
#gRegor`Important to remember that most people have no context to our initial replies
#gRegor`I don't think KevinMarks tweet appears much like sealioning, but having followed Ashe for a while and seeing a lot of the crap she's dealt with, I think I can pretty safely say it will come off as aggressive.
#KevinMarks___Ashe and Lynne are both people I have had twitter conversations with in the past, but I can see that a many hours later response to them discussing indieweb dismissively will look sealiony
#gRegor`Ah. Well it's good that you've had conversations with them before.
#gRegor`In that case a pre-emptive apology/re-phrasing of the question might not be a bad idea.
#ben_thatmustbemeahh, yeah, the subdomain bit is pretty important i think
benwerd joined the channel
#ben_thatmustbemeplus, its pretty trivial to register a domain, and will get easier and easier
#cuibonobocreating services that identify people by domain instead of by phone / email is key -- then a savvy phone or internet provider might pick up on the trend and start giving out domains with their plans
#tantekcuibonobo: or perhaps we can develop sufficient open standards based comms (e.g. webRTC / FF Hello) to make "phone" providers unnecessary and even obsolete.
#ben_thatmustbemetantek, I agree it isn't self controlled, but I don't know that the world can go to having everyone have their own domain without some intermediate step, namely indieweb friendly for as much as possible
#tantekben_thatmustbeme: of course we want to encourage indieweb /friendly silos as much as possible
#ben_thatmustbemei don't care if people want to not own their own data, so long as I can own mine and everyone interoperates
#tantekhowever, we should not call silos "indie" in any sense, as that propagates that aforementioned illusion and dilutes the good work that people here are doing
#tantekcall a friendly silo just that, not something else.
#tantekwe could even sort / rank them by friendliness
#tantekand even document when their friendliness goes up and down
#cuibonobotantek: agreed. the goal would be to make domains the only piece of identifying info you need to give out, and from your domain you can control info about you and means of communication
j12t joined the channel
#tantekcuibonobo: I'm trying to actively "live" that as I no longer have or give out a phone number - I give people my tantek.com slash contact URL which even non-tech people (but with smart phones) are able to understand / use (and some/most even add to their home screen, realizing it's more convenient than having to enter a bunch of data into a contacts app)
#tantekthe key bit is this - they're able to use my contact URL, *without* having to have a domain of their own or give up their phone number
#tantekand about 10% of them respond with hey that's cool how can I get one?
#tantekI'd say something like "no argument from me. I support your independent creative and constructive efforts in whatever form they take." but I'd be afraid of being labeled with some new "-ism" or "-ing" term that I haven't heard before like "sealioning".
#tantekalso, since KevinMarks and ben_thatmustbeme have already replied to that thread, any more @-replies there would likely look some form of outnumbering which would likely not be productive either.
#petermolnarI'd simply ignore tweets that lack context but I'm European :)
#ben_thatmustbemeagreed, I was hesitant to even give a second response
#tantekben_thatmustbeme: right. I think it's better if we spend more time listening and documenting apparent criticisms rather than responding.
#tantekben_thatmustbeme: we can listen and attempt to piece things together over time without "demanding" to see the argument
#tantek!tell benwerd Known feature request, when doing a "photo" post in particular, show a pop-up with suggested sharing licenses for the photo, e.g. CC0, CC-BY, CC-BY-NC etc. feel free to pick a set you think is useful (perhaps at least include CC0 to be indiewebcamp wiki friendly :) )
#Loqibenwerd: tantek left you a message 15 seconds ago: Known feature request, when doing a "photo" post in particular, show a pop-up with suggested sharing licenses for the photo, e.g. CC0, CC-BY, CC-BY-NC etc. feel free to pick a set you think is useful (perhaps at least include CC0 to be indiewebcamp wiki friendly :) ) http://indiewebcamp.com/irc/2015-03-23/line/1427126581180
#cuibonoboobviously i can't speak for ashe, but based on her ordeal with gittip (now gratipay) and her essays, the 'public persona' of indieweb reflects people that are very 'open'
#benwerdThis is also useful for Internet Archive integration.
#tantekbenwerd: and for Flickr POSSEing - you can POSSE the license with the photo!
#cuibonoboi.e. you provide contact information directly on your website, publicly display geolocation, etc.
#benwerdAh! I didn't realize they had that in the API. Good call!
#cuibonoboand that 'openness' is diametrically opposed to ashe's world
#tantekcuibonobo: interesting. there's definitely a diversity of opinions and practices re: contact info and geo info on one's site in the indieweb community.
#tantekperhaps we need to document that diversity of opinions better
#ben_thatmustbemeohh, benwerd, if you do add licensing options when posting a photo, make a note for how to do so in micropub, would love to support it
#benwerdI've had a lot of people who I've spoken to about connections, and who are appalled that we would even consider posting friends lists publicly.
#tantekben_thatmustbeme++ for properly one-upping my licensing suggestion!
#tantekbenwerd: I agree re: the challenges around public friends lists
#benwerdben_thatmustbeme It's a plugin for now. Micropub is awesome; IndieAuth is also awesome but not quite a clean fit with a large portion of Known sites (because they're multi-user)
#tantekKevinMarks: what assumptions of public posts?
#tantek(citation to / expansion of said assumptions needed)
#ben_thatmustbemehmmm, interesting. wonder how micropub can better support multi-user
#benwerdben_thatmustbeme: micropub does it perfectly; indieauth assumes a root-level domain
#benwerdWe also have per-item privacy in the Known codebase but haven't revealed it yet. Privacy is important, and assuming it's okay to be all-public is a position of privilege.
#benwerdBiggest piece of criticism I've had all year: that you have to pay to make your hosted Known site private.
#ben_thatmustbemedoes it? indieauth.com supports subdomains i believe
#tantekand that's for a very good reason (subdomains yes, subdirectories no) per /lj2006
#benwerdRight - it makes sense in the Indieweb context, just not always in the Known context. Subdomains are incredibly hard for many of our users to run.
#KevinMarks__Indieauth and webmention implicitly assume that we connect our sites to silos and that posts are public
#tantekbenwerd - and subdirectories are incredibly hard for you to secure against CORS based attacks
#tantekso how vulnerable do you want to make your users?
#tantekKevinMarks: Indieauth.com (not indieauth) yes, to one silo at least (can be a private account), yet webmention no, as aaronpk got private messaging working via webmention
#benwerdWe mitigate with domain-based namespacing (i.e., it's small groups of users, not one giant pool), but yes, you're right
#tantekKevinMarks: don't apologize for public posts so quickly, because you may be missing / obscuring the original point of why so much works better for public posts - which is to explore the problem space
#tantekit is an example of the "simpler" principle - solve the simpler problems first so they may better illuminate the harder problems
#tantekit's not public *instead of* private, but rather, public first *only because it's easier* to better understand what remains to get private posts working
#cuibonobothe approach that i've taken on my personal site is that all posts are private by default, but explicitly setting them 'public' will make them so
#ben_thatmustbemei think tantek is pointing out that from a tool building perspective, private posts are 2 systems, posting and access controls, public only involves posting. So it is better to start by building a public system and then work on the access issues.
#tantekcuibonobo: totally agreed on private by default in content creation UI - assuming we know how to make private posts
#cuibonoboben_thatmustbeme: right. that's why i built my access control first.
#butterwellPublic is easy. That's "everyone". Private is very difficult. First circle private: me. Second circle private: family? friends? Which ones?
#Loqiprivate posts refer to posts or portions of posts which are private to either the author or to a limited audience chosen by the author https://indiewebcamp.com/private
#tantekbutterwell: I encourage you to add your challenges and questions to that page ^^^ :)
#tantekcuibonobo: a lot of us have bad experiences with "privileged" technologists attempting to figure out / define how to do distributed private posts without actually building anything (c.f. FSW2010) and is why we gave up on them and just started building *something* that works even if insufficient.
#gRegor`For marginalized groups the first question probably isn't "How can I make a post?" but "How can I make a post without getting harassed/threatened?"
#tantekgRegor`: I wouldn't even assume what the first question is or could be or probably is for marginalized groups.
#gRegor`Well, sure. I'm just extrapolating that from horrible experiences I see them have repeatedly on social media
#tantekI think you need citations of those that self-represent as being from one or more marginalized groups before you can make any claims about what the first, second or third questions are.
#gRegor`So perhaps ignore the "ranking" of the questions.
#tantekjust capturing questions / needs at all - via specific citations/quotations thereof (not extrapolations - which could be misinterpreted as privilegesplaining)
#tantek.comedited /Main_Page (+375) "add an image of recent IWC next to subhead for call to actions to join, so there's an image of people to associate the "we" with" (view diff)
#tantekeveryone - I just made a semi-non-trivial edit to the "above the fold" section of the home page so I'd like your review / opinion please
#tantekadded a "Join the IndieWeb" heading to the otherwise "free floating" call to action list items below the definitional aspect at the top.
#KevinMarks2Privilege is the invisible advantage in life that accrue from being a member of the presumed default culture.
#tantekand second, embedded a photo from our recent IWC so there is 1) a photo closer to the top of the page which I think humanizes it more (reflects at least a subset of who "we" are), and 2) provides at least some context for the "we" references in the prose text.
#cuibonoboi also recall a tweet by shanley seeing a pic of an IWC and saying something to the effect of "what do i have in common with them?? no thanks"
#zachdonovanit was definitely a factor in feeling ready to jump in.
#tantekcuibonobo: indeed, and also why I wanted to put a recent photo which hopefully shows a bit more diversity
#KevinMarks2Today in siloing - twitter shipped an Android client that intercepts web urls for a captive browser, copying Facebook.
#gRegor`I was just looking for that tweet, cuibonobo
#tantekcertainly more than say the IWC SF photo from last year, which was all men except for caseorganic.
#cuibonobowhereas with the photo there is a more concrete 'do i belonge here? (y/n)'
#KevinMarks2"Encourage existing minorities within the group to take more active / visible roles" can be problematic too - this gives them extra work to do
#tantek.comedited /Main_Page (-356) "drop photo because it prompts too much of an implicit questioning of "do I belong here? y/n" by looks rather than principles/values, and the latter is what we want to focus on, perhaps re-assess with improved diversity in IWC participation" (view diff)
loic_m_ joined the channel
#petermolnarI honestly don't get this diversity issue when the whole thing we're doing is entirely voluntary
#tantekpetermolnar: "entirely voluntary" tends to amplify societal defaults, which tend to not be very diverse. Thus if we want more diversity, we must take explicit steps to break from societal defaults.
#petermolnardon't get me wrong, I'm not against anything but in my opinion not all the things should be force; obviously we should encourage everyone and anyone to join but it should not be forced
#petermolnareh I tried to re-write it 4 times and I ended up with a brutally ugly sentence, sorry
#tanteknp. it's not about forcing, but about focus of that encouragement
#tantek"we should encourage everyone and anyone to join" is an excellent start / concept, however by default it does tend to result in encouraging more of those "like yourself" than everyone/anyone. Thus the need to expilcitly reach out beyond those like yourself in attempt to actually achieve "encourage everyone and anyone"
#cuibonoboit's also important to note that seeking diversity isn't about checking a box in a political correctness checklist. improving diversity leads to broadening the perspective / knowldge of the group as a whole
#petermolnarI believe that approach is wrong; it smells like many of the religions which say mine is the one true way; those that always try to get more followers
#petermolnarthere are other religions who accept anyone but there are not spreading their words of how awesome we are
#petermolnarif people are interesting in something, they will seek out and yes, their interest should be welcoming; but it's not necessarily the interests' task to spread the word about themselves, or is it? Am I mistaken here?
#Loqipetermolnar meant to say: if people are interested in something, they will seek out and yes, their interest should be welcoming; but it's not necessarily the interests' task to spread the word about themselves, or is it? Am I mistaken here?
#KevinMarks2That was one of Lynne's objections - that we wanted her to join our 'white man "openness" movement'
#danlykeSo I'm getting my WithKnown installation up and running, and trying to use Brid.gy, and I am totally blanking on where I put my self-hosted WithKnown URL in... Do I need to create a new account because I've already created an account to experiment with my own code?
#petermolnardanlyke you don't have to; you just need to add the post url to the actual content in the syndicated copy (e.g Facebook post ); bridgy will do the rest of the work
#tantekpetermolnar: huh? you shouldn't need to do that either as Known does that for you automatically
#tantekperhaps the instructions are confusing then and could be improved?
#tantekdanlyke: where exactly are you getting "stuck" with getting things working?
snarfed joined the channel
#danlykeI may have a synchronization issue about when my tests went where, and I didn't initially notice the "See Original" link on Facebook back to my WithKnown post.
#tantekhey did Portland HWC get confirmed this week by anyone? aaronpk, bret, dietrich ?
#dietrichtantek: i cannot host this week. skizzy mars show on weds.
#danlykeBing, it's working. Thanks for clearing my head fuzz, y'all!
#tantekI have to agree with some of what petermolnar was saying - i.e. there's definitely a cultural value here of we tend to focus on people who have already committed to making a difference for themselves by themselves.
#tantekI'm less interested in asking anyone to join a "movement" than in asking hey, is there anything we can do to help you improve your own website in ways that you want to?
#tantekKevinMarks: perhaps you could put those links that you sent her on that wiki page ^^^
glennjones joined the channel
#ben_thatmustbemetantek, there was some context to it in the email as well
#butterwellIt is far easier to support diversity than to be diverse: to make a principle or product allow for both the average and the village, the common and the iconoclastic.
jernst and edrex joined the channel
#brettantek: i dont think i can this week. too much stuff going on atm :(
alanpearce joined the channel
#tantekok - sounds like we should cut Portland HWC for this week then
#tanteksince it's monday morning 2 days before and no one has stepped up to organize it
#tantek.comedited /ind.ie (+1491) "move old heartbeat description to indi.e page history since it's gone now from their page" (view diff)
#tantek.comedited /Heartbeat () "(-893) move old heartbeat description to indi.e page history since it's gone now from their page, and make this a disambiguation page for another meaning of "heartbeat" on the web" (view diff)
#tantek!tell GWG http://civichall.org/ looks/sounds like a good match for a location for an IWC NYC. Perhaps reach out to them (their email is "info@" their domain) and see what happens? The founders/leaders also did Personal Democracy Forum where I spoke on " Why We Need the #IndieWeb" last year (link in /videos ). You can reference that if that helps.
#tantekFoursquare has done a good job of 1) leading with useful to users application(s), growing that into a platform for venues, and 2) simply outsurviving every other (often hamfisted, e.g. Google Latitude or over VC-funded/hyped Gowalla, Brightkite, Loopt) independent commercial attempt at this. Background: https://medium.com/@dens/six-years-in-a-few-thoughts-on-foursquare-1ec31cbbe51c
#ben_thatmustbememeant to say "!tell tantek none listed" but did "!tell tantek, none listed"
#tantekThough previous "big players" Yelp and Facebook still have their own check-in UIs and use their leverage rather utility to grow integration, e.g. Instagram switching from using Foursquare venues to Facebook venues, and having worse venue tagging as a result.
#KevinMarksappengine login is an api provided by google for appengine developers to use google accounts that is subject to chaotic changes based on strategy changes at google.
#LoqiGWG: tantek left you a message 2 hours, 42 minutes ago: http://civichall.org/ looks/sounds like a good match for a location for an IWC NYC. Perhaps reach out to them (their email is "info@" their domain) and see what happens? The founders/leaders also did Personal Democracy Forum where I spoke on " Why We Need the #IndieWeb" last year (link in /videos ). You can reference that if that helps. http://indiewebcamp.com/irc/2015-03-23/line/1427143692145