#tantek!tell snarfed skimmed OPD proposals, thinking seems pretty sound. Maybe drop 24h restriction for original posts found through existing algorithm (since those have bidirectional links incl rel-syndication link back to POSSE copy)
#tantekI will say this, getting POSSE to work well across numerous possibilities has definitely been a lot of work! Especially to Twitter in particular, which is why this section is so long: http://indiewebcamp.com/Twitter#POSSE_to_Twitter
#tantekhmm - that post of yours is a very interesting example
#tantekit's commentary on a news article (on its own domain), including relevant quote in the reply-context citation. yet the commentary as written does not seem intended to show up as a comment on original article.
JasonO joined the channel
#GWGWhat is the difference between a reply and a comment?
#LoqiIt looks like we don't have a page for "difference between a reply and a comment" yet. Would you like to create it? http://indiewebcamp.com/s/102C
JasonO joined the channel
#tantekGWG, a reply is a post with its own permalink
dietrich joined the channel
#tanteka comment is a reply shown in the context of the original post, on the original post's permalink
#tantekhey I suppose I can define that though perhaps outside the window
#tantekThe difference between a reply and a comment is that a [[reply]] is a post with its own permalink on its own permalink, whereas a [[comment]] is a reply shown in the context of the original post, on the original post's permalink.
#GWGNow I'm back to my crisis of faith when I couldn't decide if I wanted to favorite, like, or bookmark
#tantekGWG, I think you are breaking new ground with the combination of interesting post types and POSSE, perhaps that is why you are finding it challenging, you are doing things and combining things as others have not done before.
#tantekGWG, does your reply UI on your site have a field for (optionaly) manually entering the tweet POSSE copy of the post you're replying to, so that you can do POSSE tweet threading?
#tantekthat is, you could have POSSEd your reply to Twitter, with an in-reply-to-status-id of 637400305257222144, which would have threaded your POSSE copy with the POSSE copy of the original article!
#GWGtantek: No, it actually doesn't. I haven't gotten basic presentation on the silo down. Advanced presentation would be next
#GWGI hadn't even thought of threading yet, I admit
#tantekGWG, I (in Falcon) have a field for (optionally) manually entering the tweet POSSE copy of the post I'm replying to because my Falcon code is not yet smart enough to auto-populate it using rel-syndication from the original.
#tantekGWG, threading is essentially for when you want to reply to indieweb /note posts which themselves have tweet POSSE copies.
#tantekperhaps I should try to package up just the Falcon code that I have that implements /Twitter#POSSE_to_Twitter , just to see if it would be helpful.
#mblaneyMy post options to add a title and send to twitter aren't mutually exclusive, so at least when just the title appears in a tweet I can add the link back then too.
#GWGI just don't know what that would look like in my POST UI.
davidmead joined the channel
#tantekGWG, it's another one-line field, perhaps right above the "content" field where you type the post content
#tantekin reply to URL: [________________________________]
#mblaneyhi GWG, my sympathies UI is hard. would much prefer just a text box for input if possible.
JasonO joined the channel
#GWGThe code I use for rel-syndication URLs is a box with one URL per line
JasonO joined the channel
#GWGI came up with that so I wouldn't have to ever code for a new service. It will display anything as a rel-syndication or u-syndication that is in the box.
lukebrooker joined the channel
#GWGmblaney: I also have to deal with pre-existing UI
#GWGI still don't know what a response to an article is, where the audience is on my site, not theirs.
j12t joined the channel
#tantekGWG, I don't either - it's a very interesting post type!
#voxpellipfefferle: did you see the language markup discussion that was a month or two ago? regarding parsing language as part of microformats?
#voxpellipfefferle: thinking that you and me are some of the few multi-language posters that's active here
#voxpellijust posted a Swedish post on my Facebook to the misfortune of all of my non-swedish friends there – thinking that the indieweb could do better than Facebook there
#voxpellipfeffer__: unless one would consider adding it as one has added "rel", but then there would be quite a bit of extra data that one might want to add – thinking this is to highlight exceptions
#tantekok here's some alternative thinking about /monoculture projects - what if we reached out (both passively and actively) to them stating a desire to federate with them? prioritize friendliest/smallest such projects first, most cynical/largest last, the assumption being that smaller projects have more incentive to federate, and it's always preferable to work with friendlier communities?
#aaronpkI think we've tried some of that in the past, even to the point of directly sending PRs
#tantekyes, we've tried some piecemeal minor efforts
#aaronpkI think we might need to be better about making the case about *why*
#tantekalright, I wanted to write one up as an example like that and have y'all take a look and iterate / provide feedback before attempting to do it on others
#ben_thatmustbemei have been slowly pokeing around at other potential candidates to federate with. I have been hoping that known and WP plugins would be enough interest to get a couple of smaller ones
#KartikPrabhudon't most new shiny silos get that credit for a while
#voxpelliaaronpk: that is weird, but I guess – supporting both xmpp and irc clients means one can use ones typical open client to connect to them and then one personally doesn't notice that it's a silo
#aaronpkyeah but those gateways are always second class citizens compared to their native clients
#voxpellithat one didn't work well last time I tried it though :P
#tantekyes, more open is often a way of saying more accessible - more accessible to more people, more accessible on more devices etc.
#aaronpkhaha yeah ngoldman works with me and maxogden visits the office now and then :)
#tantekthe same way that the Mac is "more open" than Linux. The Mac is more open to more people being able to productively use it, as opposed to requiring users meet a bar of becoming a Linux sysadmin. Such high bars are barriers, and thus make something less open.
#tantekwe have some of that same challenge here on the IndieWeb
#voxpellitantek: for me: everything that isn't an article or a shared bookmark
#voxpellinotes, likes, rsvp:s, reposts, maybe even events
#tantekvoxpelli: I don't understand the distinction then, as articles are presumably social because they can receive / show /comments/likes/reposts
#tantekand the whole point of a *shared* bookmark is to be social with it right? rather than just bookmarking it in your private browser?
#voxpellitantek: my blog will still mainly be my blog so I will keep articles up front, add a new section for links – like adactio has – and a third section for everything else
#voxpelli"social" because most of the everything else will be Twitter-like stuff
#tantekvoxpelli: I look forward to seeing your definitions evolve as you post more of this stuff on your own site first :)
#voxpelliso everyone can be social to me, but my social interactions to others will be kept in one place :)
#voxpellitantek: I have +10k tweets and 20-40 blog posts – but the latter has a longer lasting value than the former – so I want to keep them separate in the main UI (they are all part of the same full archive though)
#tantekvoxpelli: my "tweet" frequency went way down after I started posting from my own site, mostly as a result of becoming more thoughtful with my writing just because it was starting on my own site.
#tantekwhich is why I said I look forward to seeing your definitions evolve as you post more of this stuff on your own site
#tantekand eventually my notes got longer and longer and started to resemble mini-articles without titles/names
#tanteknow I post a wide spectrum of short notes, medium length notes, long notes, articles
#tantekmuch better than the false dichotomy of tweets vs. articles
#voxpelliI'm especially looking forward to upgrade my Pinboard/Instapaper use to some much more valuable sharing
#tantekGWG, since you're our WordPress Outreach Club chairman, perhaps you could reach out to @meyerweb and let him know about all the awesome IndieWeb WordPress plugins there are (Eric Meyer runs WordPress on his site meyerweb.com)
#tantekGWG, you really should reach out to @meyerweb on Twitter suggesting that he try out the IndieWeb WordPress plugins (feel free to cc: @t)
#tantekeither he'll try them out and use them, or he will give you EXCELLENT feedback about challenges in their UX, and perhaps suggestions for improving them
#tantek.comedited /Falcon (+626) "/* Itches */ add Own My Listens per last.fm design/feature changes being concerning" (view diff)
#LoqiURL design is the practice of deliberately designing URLs, in particular, permalinks, typically for a better UX for everyone who creates, reads, and shares content https://indiewebcamp.com/URL_design
#aaronpki'm still worried about autoembedding stuff on such long pages
#tantekif I've done my code right, you should be able to use cassis.js auto_link on the page on the client, and it should leave existing auto-links (from any source) alone
#aaronpkespecially because the heights of the objects are all unknown, so if you wanted to quickly scroll to the bottom of the page you couldn't, because the bottom would keep getting pushed down farther as more stuff lodas
#tanteka-ha, interesting challenge for progressive enhancement
#aaronpki would have no issue doing it on the single-line permalinks
#tantekyes! that would be a good incremental enhancement
#tantekif it helps, just copy/paste the relevant code from cassis.js autolink into your own auto-linker
#tantekthe whole auto-link function is Apache licensed (since the regex I re-used and extended was Apache)
nedorito joined the channel
#KevinMarksif I make my hovercard code more resilient, coudl add those too
#tantekcan you make it as stylistically nice as Twitter or FB's hovercards?
#KartikPrabhuaaronpk: setting full height on Element 1 should do it (from what I've read of flexbox; never used it)
#tantek.comedited /User:Tantek.com (+493) "completed: blog post about 2014-in-summary; added: updated POSSE diagram done in an atomic age design style" (view diff)