#GWG"Respond on your own site? Send me a <a href="http://indieweb.org/webmention">Webmention</a> by writing something on your website that links to this post and then enter your post URL below."
#GWGThis is the default text for the webmention form on WordPress. I want to update it to include update/delete
#GWGI was thinking of going with... "Respond on your own site, link to this post and enter the URL below to link it below. Want to update or remove the mention, just enter it again to update."
tantek, leg, eli_oat, AngeloGladding, ajft, cdchapman, snarfed, rivercat, KartikPrabhu, wolftune, KapiX, jansauer and [jeremycherfas] joined the channel; vivus left the channel
#[jeremycherfas]You don’t need the final “to update”. But I do think you need to make the first phrase a question.
cweiske, tantek, jansauer, KartikPrabhu, jihaisse, KooBaa, endi_ and sketchess joined the channel
#sketchessgood morning Loqi, good morning Indieweb.
Pierre-O, markong, tomasparks, jrb2018, jrb20181, [pfefferle], AngeloGladding, leg, marclaporte, BrAsS_mO-, jjuran_, PFMurph_, KooBaa_, ben_thatmust, deathrow1|absnt, strugee_ and bear joined the channel; jrb20181 left the channel
snarfed, wolftune, cdchapman, freescholar, tantek, kaushalmodi and KartikPrabhu joined the channel
#jgmac1106in terms of the talk of gdpr and the pixelation of webmentions could there be something like a “posse class” in an h-card to signify loose memberships. Meaning. something like <span class=“posse”>indieweb</span> and that would signify I am cool with any other site that was in the same posse with publishing my full webmentions?
freescholar and [sebsel] joined the channel
#[sebsel]gwg++ (because [chrisaldrich] told me to do so in their very nice podcast :) )
#Loqigwg has 234 karma in this channel (344 overall)
[kevinmarks] joined the channel
#[kevinmarks]Hm. That would be p-posse, but wouldn't that be a kind of organisation?
#jgmac1106[kevinmarks] yeah I was playing with the metaphor, I dodn’t want to do org as it that signifies soemthign formal. I mean what if its just ten people who like to call themselves the friends of purple buttons”
#jgmac1106and now as a post GDPR, I want to know if there is soemway to signify yeah I am vool with you displaying my stuff wherever you want
#jgmac1106but if there was a way to say I am cool with “you” but not everyone displaying my webmentions maybe there is a use case
#Zegnatu-license to a CC URL would mean you are fine with your content copied and displayed elsewhere.
#jeremycherfasI'm really not sure I understand any possible reticence about displaying webmentions. Surely if ytou don't want them displayed, you just don't send them?
#jeremycherfasLike cross-posting everywhere. If you don't want to do it, don't do it.
#jgmac1106yeah but not just the content, I am thinking about webmentions and all the talk of GDPR solutions what if there was a class in my h-card or h-entry that said I am cool with anyone elee who also have the same class in their h-card or h-entry publishing my full webmentions without pixelating or hiding any personal data
#jgmac1106I could be way out of left field on this one. Just a random idea
#jgmac1106[gRegorLive] I still do. Not sure why. Their rss bundles don’t actually produce an RSS feed
#jeremycherfasYeah, I know wherte you're coming from. I just wonder why it is an issue for anyone who creates a response that could be a webmention. Either make it one, or don't. The automated backfeed by brid.gy is the only case I can think of where this is an issue, and it seems rum to me for someone to think that it is OK for everyone to see it on Twitter, but not OK for fewer people to see it on someone's domain.
KapiX, snarfed and [chrisaldrich] joined the channel
#[kevinmarks]But anyone else could send them on your behalf
#jgmac1106I agree, and I don’t live in Europe or have any current EU clients on my server, so it is a non issue for me. I also share a simialr view of privacy. If its published on a web and somebody uses that data in ways that don’t violate ToS then tough. You give up some privacy when you hit publish and the free speech, or the finduciary responsibilities of the platform of chpice, now outweigh that privacy…but again many don’t sh
#jgmac1106[kevinmarks] yeah that is strange seeing the “hey if you see anyoen talking about my articles” also send me a webmention
#[kevinmarks]You could write a licence that limits it to a group, but there is still a fair use/fair dealing possibility for displaying your mention.
#[kevinmarks]I'll defer to dgold here, but the corollary of the "right to deletion" model is the assumption that you're indexable by default
#jeremycherfasI don't understand, kevinmarks. If I see someone else commenting on your article, and I comment on my site saying I saw someone commenting on your article, isn't that webmention from me?
KartikPrabhu joined the channel
#jeremycherfasOr are you talking about the case where someone pastes in the URL of an article not their own into my webmention box?
#[kevinmarks]No, I mean if I see someone commenting on your article and linking to you, I can send a webmention for them.
#jgmac1106but would that webmention include any bit of the hcard from you sending the webmention on someone’s behalf or only the hcard of the person who cmmented on my article
#KartikPrabhujeremycherfas: jgmac1106: webmention canbe sent by any POST request from any page as source
#KartikPrabhuso you can send webmention from the command line if you want
#KartikPrabhuwebmentions don't include any h-card. they only include the URL of the source and target pages
#jeremycherfasOn the face of it, I'd say that as the person commenting on my article, your beef is with the person who sent the webmention. But I can see that malicious intent is a possibility.
#jgmac1106Sorry just catching up on a week’s worth of reading and the indieweb pixelate your face to comply with GDPR convo was interesting. trying to understand it
#KartikPrabhujgmac1106: sure, but the point is webmentions don't care who is sending them (unless you log that ip address) and don't have any other information than the source and target URL pages
#sebselIn a way, it's not about the webmention itself at all. The webmention is just a nudge that there is something to find about page A on page B.
#Loqi[Daniel Goldsmith] Sebastian, first of all, thank you for your detailed write up on this issue. I think much of your roadmap is worthwhile, and of great interest.
I cannot, however, say that I am convinced by your contentions regarding the effect of GDPR and indieweb ...
#[kevinmarks]If you don't agree you go private, which is the case jgmac is talking about, where only those you ha e allowed to follow can see them
#jeremycherfasBut one of those private followers can send you a webmention? In which case, again, I suggest your beef is with them.
#sebseljeremycherfas There is no webmention on twitter at the moment? I think you're mixing things up.
#snarfedalso, assuming no one has already pointed out, we've regularly been conflating the *ethics* of all this with the *GDPR legal compliance*. worth remembering that they're maybe a bit related, but very different.
#dgoldI'm afraid I can't follow any of this present kerfuffle
#snarfed(imho the ethics are definitely worth our time to think about! GDPR...maybe less so.)
#jeremycherfasNo. Someone private on twitter links to, for example, a post I wrote. One of their tweeps sends me their tweet as a webmention.
#jgmac1106in fact most wenbmentions that end up on my site must people probably don’t even know they are there. I think that is part of the broader ethical conversation. Do they have a right to know they were mentioned on my blog and b do I have a repsonsibility to remive webmention if askes.
#sebselBridgy actually creates new pages with the content that's on the silo's. The webmention is sent, with those pages as targets, not the original content.
#jeremycherfasI think I'm going to wait until I get a complaint, and then deal with it if I can.
#Loqijeremycherfas has 10 karma in this channel (22 overall)
[eddie] joined the channel
#[eddie]But Bridgy only does that for public tweets
#[eddie]I agree, I think if you are posting on a public twitter account or have marked up your site with mf2, it’s a non-issue
#jgmac1106I won’t get a complaint just having fun thinking, if there was some sort of membership class could I tehn have fun back on my blog like add this border radius if the person shares the same mebership calss. Not that I could but fun future to think about
#KartikPrabhuhmm how does one complain to some website to remove their webmention?
#sebsel[eddie] And likes! But I suppose these are public as well
#[eddie]I think the real issue is putting mf2 into public themes in open source projects
#[eddie]Which we need to do to gain greater adoption but then we are opting people into this
#jgmac1106Again while agree , that public is public we must remember that people may not perceive their quasi public spaces that way. If for example a student said, “My teacher is so bad, look what this professor said about how yoiu should teach. He does none of that [link to my post] and now I get a webmention does that person have a right to know their tweet shows on my blog?
#jgmac1106[dgold] legally I agree, but ethically….jinx
#jeremycherfasMe neither, but I don't have your standing
#jeremycherfasAnd of course, there are no absolutes in ethics.
#jgmac1106people always conflate corporations with free speech without realizing that in the US legally corporations are the same etntity ads people since I think 1864
#jgmac1106therefore it is in their free speech rights to allow or not allow almost 100of whatever speech they want, of course having a legal fiduciary repsoninbility to stakeholders probably reduces most hate speech the privledged see
#jgmac1106Edventually Twitter will probably turn off the APIS (like facebook) that make this all possible and it will be a moot point
#tantekjgmac1106: which API? HTTP to retrieve HTML from a URL permalink? ;)
#Loqiscraping has -4 karma in this channel (-8 overall)
#jgmac1106’s it kids, “See how far you can get while still playing nice with silos”
#jgmac1106will do was just trying to keep it philosophical and given my lack of dev knowledge with this stuff I hate moving discussions there. Fugre thats a place for code not questions
#tantekjgmac1106: indeed, and as soon as you feel tempted to say "microformat" or propose one, definitely jump to dev with that please :)
#Loqi[jmac] Nate Cull's attitude on Twitter is admittedly rather more acid than I would have employed, but it does back up my observation that literally nobody I know outside of these IRC channels (and the one blogger I follow who got me into it) has heard of In...
#jgmac1106this is what is quite different in the education blogging circles. As indieweb has grown over the last 12 years so have educational bloggers. Might be one of the few corners of the web still functioing in a blogosphere. Many are aware of the #indieweb stuff but don’t know how it works or tried way to early before WordPress plug-ins were mature.
#jgmac1106There is also a built in commuity that share core values, andits the community I know
marclaporte joined the channel
#jgmac1106If only a small circle in the dev community are talking indieweb and mircoformats then the answer is simple, talk to other communities outside of dev circles
#jgmac1106the conversartion is hard, however. We first need to focus on writing documentation not for devs, that’s my starting point. What is the experience of the community I want to bring to indieweb, how do they inderstand indieweb, what toold do they use and understand, where do they have problmes.
#jgmac1106From this insight we can write better dcoumenation folks can then fork for different communities
#jgmac1106copying and pasting only my comments to meta so they are on record
#tantekand yes, meta is good for community development like conversations / thoughts like this!
marclaporte1 joined the channel
#[kevinmarks]Going back to the ethics conversation, there is an interesting line in practice, which is that media organisations feel free to quote tweets, but ask permission for video or images
#tantekkevinmarks is that practice documented anywhere? or just passive convergence? or ... ?
#[kevinmarks]At one point, Twitter did link from the tweet to the media stories that quoted it. Maybe @benward can tell us why that stopped.
arne joined the channel; arne left the channel
#tantekbenward left twitter a while ago, and I think I still see those media stories lists mentioned
#[kevinmarks]Linking to a narrower licence with rel-licence may be a good way to express this, but without coming up with a converged one like creative commons did, that may be trickier.
#jgmac1106excpet coming from someone who said I was a blogger but now I am a journlist pangs just a little bit more
tglobe2 joined the channel
#@frankmeeuwsenVoor alle deelnemers op #blogpraat die geen WordPress, Blogger of ander kant-en-klaar template hebben maar vooral vanuit een Indieweb gedachte bezig zijn, onderstaande blogpost is zeer de moeite waard! (twitter.com/_/status/993562970558025728)
#schmartywell i hope somebody cheesemarks this because i cleaned up my GIF posting client based on lots of good feedback here and it has a home on the web now at: https://kapowski.schmarty.net/
#LoqiIt looks like we don't have a page for "Kapowski" yet. Would you like to create it? (Or just say "Kapowski is ____", a sentence describing the term)
tantek, sebsel, wolftune, KartikPrabhu, benwerd, [jeremycherfas] and KooBaa joined the channel
#gRegorLoveA nice testimonial about #indieweb chat from jmac: "Of all the Freenode IRC channels with populations of more than 100 that I’ve spent any time on, the people of #indieweb have proven among the most friendly and welcoming, always quick to answer newcomers’ questions with no trace of mockery, feigned surprise, or bad taste. This has helped a great deal with my own ever-deepening interest in and respect for IndieWe
[pfefferle], cdchapman, KartikPrabhu, frank, Loqi_, webhat_, hs0ucy_, danyao, chrisaldrich, marinin_, kupad, pniedzielski[m], M0x3F[m], grantcodes, M-mxuribe, cuibonobo[m], jigawatt, jgmac1106, marclaporte and benwerd joined the channel
#@megarush1024Working on a new “Subscribe” page for http://arush.io because WordPress is celebrating its fifteenth year on May 27 and I think the best way to join that celebration is to bail on big social on my own terms and get back to the basics with my own sites. #Indieweb #WP15 (twitter.com/_/status/993602825413373952)
[pfefferle], freescholar, [eddie], brehaut, [kevinmarks], benwerd and tantek joined the channel
#tantekwonders if Bridgy Publish will POSSE an animated GIF to Twitter etc.