#indieweb 2020-08-29
2020-08-29 UTC
Ani and [chrisaldrich] joined the channel
# [chrisaldrich] How to know you're still upset over Google Reader all these years later: https://twitter.com/mathowie/status/1299480141760872448
# @mathowie my friends: you need to let it go and move on with your life me: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EgiuTMVUMAANsAB.jpg (twitter.com/_/status/1299480141760872448)
KempfCreative, bltavares, avalos, [tantek] and [fluffy] joined the channel
# [fluffy] so, got in a conversation with someone who's been pretty frequently critical of IndieWeb to me. I won't try to characterize some of his recurring complaints but this might be worth a read. https://mastodon.social/@fluffy/104768852508031257
# Loqi [fluffy 💜] New post: Plaidophile: Incremental progress https://beesbuzz.biz/blog/3876-Incremental-progressLately I’ve been seeing a lot of criticism about the IndieWeb movement based on the notion that everything that comes out of it is biased towards people ...
# KartikPrabhu yeah I don't understand the criticism. as far as I see, if you have a personal website and post to it you are indieweb. Everything else is a bonus
# KartikPrabhu it seems like a strawman argument
# KartikPrabhu exactly! most things are optional. Even webmention, IMO
# KartikPrabhu even microformats
# KartikPrabhu have a website and post on it, that's it for me
wolftune joined the channel
# KartikPrabhu also, we talk about performance, costs of hosting a website, costs of admin etc.. constantly
# KartikPrabhu yes ^ that came up in the last HWC West coast
# KartikPrabhu yes!
# [fluffy] Here's his indieweb wiki user page, FWIW: https://indieweb.org/User:Felix.plesoianu.ro
# KartikPrabhu people here are definitely open to criticism. I myself have criticized a lot of things
# [fluffy] Anyway, I guess the reason I bring this up is there's *something* that's causing people to continually have this impression of IndieWeb and maybe there's things we can do to address this perception, and maybe have better outreach. Do we still have the ongoing initiative to give indieweb.org a better landing page?
# KartikPrabhu [fluffy]: yes. It is valuable feedback to see how we can phrase things better
# KartikPrabhu even if one might think "some people won't change" it will be good to improve for the new people who come this way
# KartikPrabhu that would be weird, since most Indiweb sites are not ActivityPub/Mastodon based!
# KartikPrabhu are they?
# [fluffy] This is the main article I had in mind: https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/can-indie-social-media-save-us
# KartikPrabhu "artisanal" is such an annoying adjective; I blame the "hipsters" ;)
# KartikPrabhu yes! that also came up on the last HWC WEst coast; how /why do you deviate from the reverse-choronological timeline/feed model
# KartikPrabhu for me it works, but for others it might not and that is good
# KartikPrabhu people can make their websites anyway they want
nickodd joined the channel
# KartikPrabhu this a very nice tag-filter design: https://jasonsantamaria.com/articles/
# [fluffy] I should probably fake-SPAify the tag browsing on https://biz.beesbuzz.biz/ - shouldn't be hard to do and it'd make things look much nicer.
# KartikPrabhu right the JS parts could easily be optional
# KartikPrabhu :confused: I don't know what is being reinvented; and real names are definitely not something that is insisted up on
jonnybarnes joined the channel
# KartikPrabhu like lot of the IRC names here are nicknames. Also I don't have an actual picture either
# Loqi [Claude LeChat] @fluffy Right here: https://indieweb.org/Getting_Started#Set_up_your_home_page Maybe it doesn't seem to insist so much on real names (and photos) specifically, but it's very much implied throughout. See the /h-card page, or better yet /homepage
# Loqi It looks like we don't have a page for "real name" yet. Would you like to create it? (Or just say "real name is ____", a sentence describing the term)
# Loqi Naming is hard https://indieweb.org/name
# Loqi A personal domain is a domain name that you personally own, control, and use to represent yourself on the internet https://indieweb.org/identity
deltab joined the channel
# [fluffy] I’m getting close to the point of giving up again until the next time he slides into my mentions after I write something about IndieWeb. https://mastodon.social/@fluffy/104770856729703790
# [fluffy] This feels like a good stopping point: https://meow.social/@claude/104770866889130541 https://mastodon.social/@fluffy/104770877728649508
[fluffy]1, rMdes_4, IRCsumm, lahacker, ramsey, flaki_ and nickodd joined the channel
jbove, voxpelli and KartikPrabhu joined the channel
beko, rEnr3n, avalos, jonnybarnes, wolftune, kensp and [chrisaldrich] joined the channel
# [chrisaldrich] GWG++ for https://github.com/dshanske/date-archive-order so quick after the conversation earlier this week.
jonnybarnes joined the channel
# [chrisaldrich] Riffing on the earlier mention of time-based order, I had meant to bring up the completely non-ordered set up on Kicks Condor's site at the moment. It becomes a massively large single page and one sort of flies in and out of various close up views of it while exploring.
[jeremycherfas] joined the channel
# [jeremycherfas] [fluffy]++ for patience, tolerance and goodwill. I would have given up. And I am reminded of the Jonathan Swift quote paraphrased as “you cannot reason someone out of a position that they did not reason themselves into”.
# [chrisaldrich] Took me a minute to remember the reference, but Kicks site in it's incarnation a few clicks in actually has a larger map feel and reminds me a bit of Mark Bernstein’s 1998 essay Hypertext Gardens...
# [chrisaldrich] [fluffy]++ for being generally awesome every day 🙂
[James_Gallaghe] joined the channel
# [James_Gallaghe] Good morning everyone!
# [chrisaldrich] We didn't touch on the real name/pseudonym question this week, but I feel like there were a few discussions about how to represent one's self with one or more websites and how to split personal/professional.
# [chrisaldrich] Good morning btw!
avalos joined the channel
# [chrisaldrich] There was a question about how to choose a URL and some examples there as well. While many have names as urls even that's not necessary...
# [chrisaldrich] It may be the case that some of us have done it so long that we haven't managed to document some of these things or suggestions of how to work around them for those who may want/need suggestions about how to better protect themselves online.
# [chrisaldrich] What is name?
# Loqi Naming is hard https://indieweb.org/name
# [chrisaldrich] and I just read the response aaron got... how quickly I forgot...
# [chrisaldrich] What are nymwars?
# Loqi nymwars is the name for the assumption, made by facebook and google+ that enforcing "real names" improves a social website; this was opposed by many people who have very good reasons for pseudonymity or anonymity https://indieweb.org/nymwars
# [chrisaldrich] What is anonymity?
# [chrisaldrich] what is pseudonymity?
# Loqi Pseudonymity is the concept of having an anonymous identity that is the same across multiple sessions or websites https://indieweb.org/pseudonymity
# [chrisaldrich] that anonymity page is so old it has no definition! These could be better linked and filled out for sure...
leg joined the channel
# [chrisaldrich] I did read a post this week by a community member considering creating a website for a pen name they were using to write novels in a genre they didn't feel might fit in with their personal/professional web presence.
# [chrisaldrich] I'll ask to see if they'd document it publicly on the wiki...
# [chrisaldrich] We could certainly have more examples of these types of patterns to help serve as guideposts for others who might be served by pros/cons and personal experiences in how to navigate these waters.
jonnybarnes joined the channel
# avalos Why does the indieweb.org wiki has a definition for everything?
# avalos Lol.
# [chrisaldrich] Not everything... some of them have snarkinitions 😁. ( Though we're even progressively working on that....)
# avalos Really? 😂
wiedi joined the channel; leg left the channel
# [chrisaldrich] Having /fun is an important /principle....
KartikPrabhu, dckc and jonnybarnes joined the channel
# [chrisaldrich] I took a pass at breaking away the redirect of /name if anyone wants to iterate on it, particularly for welcoming language in line with our /principles.
# [chrisaldrich] What is name?
# Loqi A name can be an important part of one's online identity and can be almost anything one chooses to represent themselves https://indieweb.org/name
[chrisaldrich], jonnybarnes and [KevinMarks] joined the channel
# [KevinMarks] name << Falsehoods programmers believe about names https://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names/
# [KevinMarks] name << Falsehoods Programmers Believe About Names – With Examples https://shinesolutions.com/2018/01/08/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names-with-examples/
# Loqi ok, I added "Falsehoods programmers believe about names https://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names/" to the "See Also" section of /name https://indieweb.org/wiki/index.php?diff=72341&oldid=72340
# Loqi ok, I added "Falsehoods Programmers Believe About Names – With Examples https://shinesolutions.com/2018/01/08/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names-with-examples/" to the "See Also" section of /name https://indieweb.org/wiki/index.php?diff=72342&oldid=72341
[Ana_Rodrigues] joined the channel
# [Ana_Rodrigues] Good morning everyone!
# [Ana_Rodrigues] [fluffy]++ for your blog post and the above patient convo. Gave lots to think about.
[fluffy] joined the channel
# [Ana_Rodrigues] Regarding pseudoanonymity: That’s what happened to me. In 2012 when I came “back online” I didn’t want to be easily found by my last name. Which is why my username and “main domain” are ohhelloana and kept a “Ana Rodrigues” domain for work.
# [Ana_Rodrigues] Only in 2018 I started to share my last name online.
# [Ana_Rodrigues] I will try to document this somewhere soon and link it. Unsure if it helps anyone.
kensp and [James_Gallaghe] joined the channel
# [James_Gallaghe] Morning, [Ana_Rodrigues]!
# [James_Gallaghe] [Ana_Rodrigues] What were you doing before 2012 (when you were presumably “not online”)?
# [James_Gallaghe] I’m fascinated by the concept of pseudonymity as well.
jonnybarnes joined the channel
# [James_Gallaghe] My issue is that I feel like I am doing work without getting any credit for it as my own. For instance, I’ve been thinking about doing a pseudonymous quantified self experiment. I like the idea because it would give me privacy but, on the other hand, I wouldn’t be able to talk about it with people like this community 🙂
jonnybarnes joined the channel
# [James_Gallaghe] I feel the same way about sharing my name. I prefer to use “jamesgoca” on as many platforms as I can. I know that “jamesgoca” is linked to my real name but I just don’t like the idea of someone Googling my full name and seeing a list of every service that I’ve signed up for in the past.
# [James_Gallaghe] (It’s a small distinction but one that matters to me)
# KartikPrabhu [Ana_Rodrigues]++ very nice article on Smashing Mag
# KartikPrabhu [Ana_Rodrigues] and [James_Gallaghe] : feel free to document what you find on /names, even if you are unsure that it helps anyone
# KartikPrabhu even if does not help anyone now, it might later
# KartikPrabhu and might encourage others to think of this issue
# KartikPrabhu I used a "nickname" online for a long time, but when I got my domain I did switch to my name since I felt this was "my space"© ;) But that was my decision, others might use a pseudonym even for their domain or any web identity and tat is their choice
# Zegnat Name and identity discussions are always interesting. I too felt like the definition of mf2 name got very close to "real name", which is why I have previously argued that maybe nickname (or a similar term for display name) is more suited in places (e.g. https://github.com/indieweb/indieauth/issues/31#issuecomment-468918215)
# Loqi [Zegnat] As [mentioned in #23](https://github.com/indieweb/indieauth/issues/23#issuecomment-414152219) @aaronpk (at least at that point) wanted to keep IndieAuth as straight-forward as possible. I wasn’t there for the original discussion that started this i...
# [James_Gallaghe] There’s parts of my identity that I feel comfortable sharing, just not openly, too. For instance, I don’t broadcast my age on my website but people generally know that I am young. I totally get why people choose pseudonyms.
# KartikPrabhu yup! it isn't all or nothing
jonnybarnes and [grantcodes] joined the channel
# [grantcodes] Yay, got my website synced up to my daily theme generator now 😄 so my website, twitter, phone and computer backgrounds are all in sync
jeremy, jonnybarnes and [KevinMarks] joined the channel
# [KevinMarks] The h-card heritage from vcard does imply given names to some extent. In practice though a lot of address books have nicknames in
[jeremycherfas] joined the channel
# KartikPrabhu there is a p-nickname no?
# [KevinMarks] Yes, that is from vcard too. But if its a name you're known as then name is better. One reason we de-emphasised the structured names was because of their restrictive framing
jeremy-, thelounge24478, KartikPrabhu, neceve, jonnybarnes, anotheryou, fauno, nickodd and [manton] joined the channel
[snarfed] joined the channel
# [snarfed] right. afaik indieweb doesn’t take a stand, we’re open to real names, pseudonymity, and anonymity. (eg https://commentpara.de/)
wolftune joined the channel
# petermolnar could the source of confusion be the word itself "name"?
# petermolnar does the word "name" indirectly suggests real name?
KempfCreative, twomanytacos and [fluffy] joined the channel
# [fluffy] So hey could we not rush to wikify every conversation about indieweb stuff, or think a bit more about what gets put on the wiki? https://meow.social/@claude/104773474402077087
wolftune joined the channel
# petermolnar Unless someone comes with the mindset that believes the previous wording stood for something, the new one is making it different, thus not standing up for our initial beliefs.
[jeremycherfas] joined the channel
[chrisaldrich] and [KevinMarks] joined the channel
# [KevinMarks] Very indieweb relevant thread https://twitter.com/doctorow/status/1299741637116010502?s=20
# @doctorow The copyright scholar James Boyle (@thepublicdomain) has a transformative way to think about political change. He tells a story about how the word "ecology" welded together a bunch of disparate issues into a movement. 1/ (twitter.com/_/status/1299741637116010502)
# deltab less extreme: using "name/pseudonym" in some places
wolftune, shoesNsocks and jonnybarnes joined the channel
# [chrisaldrich] [grantcodes]++ for syncing daily theme generator... I can only see portions of it obviously, but how cool to have even your visual identity follow you across the web and technology!
# [chrisaldrich] What is food?
# Loqi Food is a post type that represents eating or drinking particular food or drink https://indieweb.org/food
# [chrisaldrich] [James_Gallaghe] I just ran across your awesome looking coffee page https://coffee.jamesg.app/, you should totally add that to the /food examples ^^
# petermolnar there should be an "office sludge" category on that page
[James_Gallaghe] joined the channel
# [James_Gallaghe] [chrisaldrich]
# [James_Gallaghe] Thanks for the comment! I shall. I haven’t updated that page in a few days.
# [James_Gallaghe] Should it be part of my main blog or should I keep it as a separate page? I’ve already written the code for the blog version but I have not pushed it yet.
# [chrisaldrich] Also, your post on quantified self has got me starting a long-overdue stub page for that topic as well.
# [chrisaldrich] Who is [James_Gallaghe]?
# [chrisaldrich] If you'd like to James, you can wikify yourself as well: https://indieweb.org/wikifying
# [James_Gallaghe] I need to wikify myself 🙂
# [James_Gallaghe] I’ve got so much to do on the IndieWeb. I feel like I should be writing a manual.
kensp joined the channel
# [chrisaldrich] Small posts on your website over time while syndicating links to them to the wiki will accomplish much the same thing and prevent it from feeling like work.
# [James_Gallaghe] Yeah haha. I’m probably going to blog a bit more about the IndieWeb soon. I’ve been in a bit of a funk lately so I’m trying not to commit to anything big.
wolftune, jonnybarnes and kensp joined the channel
# [chrisaldrich] What is quantified self?
# Loqi Quantified self refers both to the cultural phenomenon of self-tracking with technology and to a community of users and makers of self-tracking tools, many of whom are using their personal websites to own their data https://indieweb.org/quantified_self
# [chrisaldrich] ^^ I've fleshed out a stub (finally) for that if anyone wants to add some examples. Not sure how we've had multiple camp sessions on it and it doesn't have it's own page...
# [chrisaldrich] quantified self << 2020-08-24 [https://jamesg.app/ James Gallagher] [https://jamesg.app/2020/08/24/quantified-self-and-the-indieweb.html Quantified Self And The Indieweb]
# Loqi ok, I added "2020-08-24 [https://jamesg.app/ James Gallagher] [https://jamesg.app/2020/08/24/quantified-self-and-the-indieweb.html Quantified Self And The Indieweb]" to the "See Also" section of /quantified_self https://indieweb.org/wiki/index.php?diff=72363&oldid=72362
# [James_Gallaghe] I’ll take this in tomorrow and flesh it out.
# [James_Gallaghe] In fact, I might livestream a build of my new QS site. Would anyone tune in? :)
# [James_Gallaghe] If one person says yes I am doing it. I haven’t live-streamed since I tried to build a project in 24 hours.
KartikPrabhu, KempfCreative and jonnybarnes joined the channel; nickodd left the channel
# Loqi [Doug Belshaw] This week’s microcast answers a question from John Johnston about federation and the IndieWeb.
https://thoughtshrapnel.com/2020/01/01/microcast-81/ https://thoughtshrapnel.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Libertarianism-groups-diagram.png
# Loqi audio is a sound recording indieweb post that is spoken or otherwise created by the author of a site https://indieweb.org/Audio
# Loqi audio is a sound recording indieweb post that is spoken or otherwise created by the author of a site https://indieweb.org/sound
# Loqi It looks like we don't have a page for "gramophone" yet. Would you like to create it? (Or just say "gramophone is ____", a sentence describing the term)
# aaronpk it's... rough, but it works https://gramophone.p3k.io/
wolftune joined the channel
jonnybarnes joined the channel
# Loqi Screech is a simple app for posting audio content, such as podcasts, to your website using Micropub https://indieweb.org/Screech
# jacky something like https://jacky.wtf/feeds/podcast/$TAG
[snarfed] joined the channel
[tantek] joined the channel