#Loqi[Christopher Allan Webber] @ghost @davidsgallant @polymerwitch Aside from blocking, a flag on a user's profile might be a good approach. (A site could default to one or another setting and maybe also let users set the option.) Def understand some might not want to be searchab...
#tantekwell that's interesting. public blacklash against indexing of public posts?!?
#Loqi[Sandro Hawke] @Gargron and in practice, how can you stop broader search from being implemented by someone in an open system? If users want it, someone will provide it.
#tantekdo we need a notion of "no robots" in audience?
#tantek^^^ that's how you "prevent it" with good actors (search engines that obey robots.txt / meta robots)
#cwebberwhy am I not seeing Sandro's posts show up
#tantekyou let users say "noindex" (copyedit for UI), and then meta robots noindex them on their profile / stream page and all their permalink pages
#ajordanoffhand this discussion seems ridiculous to me. if you don't want things to be searchable you *have* to have some notion of privacy. can't just make them public
#ajordanso there's two discussions that *seem* to be happening, AFAICT
#ajordanone is that the tool doesn't seem to have a way to opt-out of being searched or in other words, it doesn't have/respect something like robots.txt
#tantekcwebber, the "can ignore it" is not a problem in practice for robots.txt and search engines
#ajordanand the second is the idea that there shouldn't be full-text search generally
#ajordanI think when I said stuff ^^^ up there I was conflating the two, which was a mistake
#ajordanwhat I meant was: the first one strikes me as a real problem. people should be able to control whether they're in search engines, even if there's no technical restriction to back up that control
#ajordanthe idea that no one should build full-text search on stuff that's already public "because" just doesn't make sense to me
#ajordan*that's* what I meant when I said "there needs to be some notion of privacy" if that's the expectation. "privacy" here might mean "disallow in robots.txt is on by default" but like... idk
#ajordanGagron's response doesn't really make sense to me
#cwebberit's a tricky space. one instance pointed to "I don't want my posts to be indexed because I've tagged a lot of my stuff with trans stuff, and I don't want to be targeted for harassment"
#cwebberthough, I think that maybe users should also be made more clearly aware that these systems are defaulting to "your stuff *is* out there and public"
#tantekthis would be a good topic for the SWICG telcon
#cwebbertantek: I worked for 16 hours on monday and so after the call I got almost nothing done because I was pretty burnt out. I'll try to get up the wiki page
#tantekI may start documenting my own personal use-cases for why I have done so in the past (and may want to do so again in the future)
#tanteke.g. one example was posting publicly to humans who would be reading my "feed" about people / personal things that people were ok with discussing publicly, but I didn't want to unintentionally affect their public "googling" search results
#tantekajordan, I started my blog in 2002, blocking robots.txt for I think 2-3 years. It was a conscious decision at the time because I wanted more perceived freedom to experiment with what I felt comfortable posting, without immediately exposing everything to search results.
#tantekI do remember when I flipped on robots I think it was either in 2004 or 2005, then eventually retroactive back to 2004; at the time I remember explicitly thinking that I would trade search engine surfacing of some technical posts for stopping posting some more personal posts
#tantekif you're curious, you can view for yourself starting here: tantek.com/log/2002/08.html (no archive links, just update YYYY/MM.html accordingly)
#cwebberlooks like I have to find another mastodon instance until I'm running my own public activitypub server and mastodon is federtaing with it
dmitriz joined the channel
#cwebberlooks like toot.cat is going whitelist-only on the nodes it's federating with, probably not the best route for me since I'm trying to spread information about federation amongst the fediverse