#LoqiA bookmarklet is a web browser bookmark that runs javascript commands on the current page; indieweb bookmarklets are often useful for responding to the current page https://indieweb.org/bookmarklet
#gRegorThere's some Markdown format in these if anyone would like to go through and convert to MediaWiki syntax. I'm mostly not cleaning them up, just archiving as-is for now.
#[tantek]So, forums (or other alternative community tools) capjamesg, [Paul_Robert_Ll]
#[tantek]Jacky, re wiki and having a barrier be a domain to edit, that's a deliberate design decision, especially to keep modtax down to a minimum. Pretty sure we have covered that before in chat and should have an FAQ for it.
[Jeremy_Keith] joined the channel
#[tantek]Short version IIRC is if people without a domain want to contribute to content to the community, they can still use their own site or some social media to post about the IndieWeb and it will show up in #indieweb-stream where someone else in the community can see it and manually opt-in incorporate it into the wiki if it's appropriate
#[tantek]And second, the wiki barrier encourages folks to show up here in chat first, where they can get a better 2-way understanding of the community before editing or doing any potentially damaging changes to a place they just showed up
#[tantek]Third, folks joining via chat can do minimal beginner additions to the wiki with the < < command and frankly IMO that's sufficient for good faith beginner contributions to the wiki
#[tantek]Jacky, perhaps fourth, the barrier is deliberate also because we have very strong nudge here to get people to direct their creative energy FIRST into their indieweb presence and only SECOND into community contributions. Like if your primary interest isn't actually walking the indieweb walk yourself, why are you here?
#[tantek]This also helps deter "drive by" reply guys and other "talkers" from damaging our community resource with their purely hypothetical handwaving
#[tantek](If they weren't being hypothetical talkers then they would actually setup their indieweb presence first instead of just talking about it)
jacky joined the channel
#[tantek][Paul_Robert_Ll] are you projecting the main #indieweb channel for folks in the room to see in real time?
#Loqi[Paul_Robert_Ll] has 32 karma in this channel over the last year (45 in all channels)
lazcorp joined the channel
#tantek.comedited /accessibility (+516) "dfn indieweb relevance, simplify a little, flatten heading levels a bit, note to do to focus page on IndieWeb relevant content and link out for broader web accessibility resources" (view diff)
#aaronpkaha, it assumes 00:00 end time for multi-day events rather than 23:59
#aaronpki guess this is why i hadn't planned on multi-day events getting a start/end time, because there are always weird things like this
#aaronpklike what happens in the middle of the night between days? it shouldn't show the "join now" link during that time
#aaronpki think the answer is to create a sub-event with the actual start/end time of each day with the zoom link, that way it is clear what the actual schedule is
#aaronpkmy thought was it could also be used for individual sessions, especially with the zoom integration that creates a new zoom event from the website
#[tantek]especially a multi-day event across a US DST timezone change!
#[tantek]aaronpk yes! it's Joschi's supercool 360degree camera and Android device that can directly connect to Zoom (though he has to use a remote control to enter username etc. when logging into zoom, like TV remotes and streaming UIs)
#Loqiprocrastinalex has 2 karma in this channel over the last year (3 in all channels)
[Al_Abut] joined the channel
#[tantek][Al_Abut] the "momentum" in chat vs staying welcoming to new folks is an interesting trade-off / challenge
#[tantek]IMO when such "momentum" is discouraging new folks from participating, I think it's very much worth "breaking" that momentum (which is almost always from experienced folks in the community) and nudging folks to the more appropriate channel(s) accordingly
#[tantek]like if we really want people to show up to #indieweb and feel encouraged and able to "just chat about blogging", then the flipside of that is reducing the amount of threads/noise there that don't have to do with "what you want to do on your personal site as a user"
#[Al_Abut]Ha! I just experienced one of the aspects of chat that I forgot about - I tried to switch the conversation over to here but then had like a few hundred messages to catch up on first.
#[tantek]if new people see a bunch of spec/jargon/code talk then they immediately conclude "oh this indieweb thing must only be for developers" β that's literally repeatedly a problem in that someone posts about that every month or so
#[Al_Abut]I think I see what youβre saying? But also Iβve only had one coffee and it hasnβt kicked in yet π
#[tantek]if new people see a bunch of community-admin/devops talk then they immediately conclude "oh this chat must only be for admins of the community" and then again they are immediately discouraged from participating
#[Al_Abut]Sorry to post and run, this is such bad ettiquette but Iβm heading out the door to (finally) see Dune 2. Just wanted to throw some love towards the newbie cause!
#[tantek]point is, we have to prioritize being /welcoming to new people in the main channel (over "momentum" for experienced people) if we want to keep being open and encouraging to new folks in the community
[contact898] joined the channel
#[contact898]> if new people see a bunch of spec/jargon/code talk then they immediately conclude "oh this indieweb thing must only be for developers" β that's literally repeatedly a problem in that someone posts about that every month or so
#[Al_Abut]The chat has actually become a big part of my daily/weekly routine, I can just empathize with the activation energy it took for that to happen and also appreciate how maybe thereβs a subtle intentionality to it. Reconciling that with being more newbie-friendly is the healthy tension
#[contact898]took me forever to try and figure out what was "for me" and what was arcane and scary
#[tantek]^ [Al_Abut] are you seeing this? this is literally what I mean. Even "just" talk about HTML+CSS can be offputting to new people, which is why that belongs in #indieweb-dev not #indieweb
#[contact898]I also think that the channel is not "for me", though - in the sense that retention is more important than recruitment
#[contact898]sorry I meant the whole IRC server really, or indieweb conversations in general. I feel like I'm part of the indieweb but not of the indieweb "builders" and here is a "builder" place, if that makes sense
#[tantek][contact898] totally makes sense and it's why we specifically try to direct all "builder" chats to the #indieweb-dev channel
#[tantek]because of exactly the experience you are talking about
#[contact898]yes, but I don't think it's a negative experience in itself!
#[tantek]it has been for a lot of people in the past unfortunately π
#[contact898]it really depends on whether you want the builders to be in #indieweb-dev or the non-builders to be in #indieweb-chat
#[contact898]and both approaches would be valid imo
#[contact898]but yeah I've been in places where the "builders" (in a non-tech space, another meaning) were constantly sent to their channels when they were getting too excited about something specific and it's very off-putting too
#[contact898]there's no objectively correct solution (otherwise we wouldn't need this conversation haha)
#[tantek][contact898] my theory is that "builders" are more tolerant (less put off?) than folks who just want to do something with their personal site, whether a page of links or blog posts, and may feel more scared/intimidated
#Loqi[preview] [Tantek Γelik] Similar to @paulgraham.com (@paulg@mas.to @paulg)βs 2008 observation about trollsΒΉ, thereβs a sort of Gresham's Law of developers (vs users): developers are willing to use a forum with a lot of users in it, but users arenβt willing to use a fo...
#[Fran]A couple more chats re chat / belonging / alternative channels today in Brighton. The risk of something like a forum ending up as a graveyard/grumpyard does exist. Long lived communities survive via a mix of individual direction (moderation) and culture (shared norms and purpose) β we already have the latter, and it seems momentum around the former (βhappy to dedicate some time, for one) . Maybe it could start with camp-alumni, later open
#[Fran]to camp-hopeful, and wider as the paths are paved and we understand the effort required, vs the value gained.
#[tantek]sounds like a reasonable and well-considered plan [Fran]!
#[tantek]Also wow at 25 participants for a max capacity/tickets of 30 event :exploding_head:
#[tantek][Paul_Robert_Ll] I hope you realize a bunch of us will be eagerly awaiting IWC Brighton 2025 planning π
#[Paul_Robert_Ll]I also wondered if a forum could be used for help for particular IndieWeb tools (like Indiekit). That means authors have a place to help users AND it means forum has people motivated to visit/moderate. I added discussions to Indiekitβs GitHub repository recently, be nice if it was located βcloserβ to community discussions.
#[tantek]That's fascinating [Paul_Robert_Ll]. Tool or service specific "support". Like we have #indieweb-wordpress for IndieWeb WordPress users, and #indieweb-known for those, but no reason to have to "wait" to make a new channel for other tools and services where the creator wants *something* to discuss them. GitHub discussions are a good start.
#[tantek]But you're right, something closer / more connected would be better
#[tantek]we do get many Bridgy / Bridgy Fed bug reports / support questions in #indieweb-dev, certainly enough to merit its own "space"
#LoqiEdinburgh is a city in Scotland that started a Homebrew Website Club meetup 2015-08-13 and held an IndieWebCamp in 2015 https://indieweb.org/Edinburgh
#[tantek][Paul_Robert_Ll] I'm trying spend what espresso energy I have left stubbing / filling out the remaining IWC Brighton 2024 wiki pages that need filling out
#[tantek]there's a few remaining. I added them to /to-do in case I fall asleep / forget and that way someone else can pick up
#[tantek][Fran] do you know Harry Reeder, is he still in Edinburgh, or is he active in any way in the community? I can't recall seeing him in a long while
#[Fran]Last met for a few HWC in 2015-16, then lost contact. He was studying in Edi, not sure if he's still around.
jacky joined the channel
#[Fran]Oh, seems he's still around from his GitHub profile π€
#tantek.comedited /Edinburgh (+110) "/* Local IndieWeb Members */ move tbrb to formerly active, no signs in chat etc for many years, welcome back whenever!" (view diff)
#tantek.comedited /Planning (+127) "/* Summit */ add specific date proposal 2024-08-25β¦26 Sunday & Monday in Portland, separate specific dates vs vague dates" (view diff)
#[tantek]signing off for a few hours. great seeing everyone at IWC Brighton. Can help with more wikifying and related gardening later tonight or maybe tomorrow.